Meet a Street Epistemologist: Pascoe Rapacci vs Cameron Bertuzzi

Key takeaways

Street Epistemology is a method of dialogue that focuses on how individuals arrive at their beliefs, rather than merely debating the validity of those beliefs.
Cameron Bertuzzi argues that beliefs should be supported by rational justification, while Pasco Rapacci emphasizes empathetic questioning as a means to explore faith.
The concept of properly basic beliefs challenges the need for evidence in faith, but raises questions about belief justification and its relationship with evidence.
The effectiveness and morality of Street Epistemology are debated, with potential concerns about its manipulative aspects and motivations.
Engaging in thoughtful discussions about faith encourages exploration and understanding, but can also highlight significant philosophical differences.

Summary

Introduction to Street Epistemology

The podcast opens with an introduction by Justin Briley, who explains the concept of Street Epistemology, detailing its rise among atheists as a method to challenge and discuss spiritual beliefs. He highlights how the methodology was popularized by Peter Boghossian and is aimed at developing a large movement seeking to deconvert individuals from faith to atheism.

Discussion with Pasco Rapacci and Cameron Bertuzzi

In this segment, Pasco Rapacci, a street epistemologist, engages in dialogue with Cameron Bertuzzi, a Christian apologist. They explore the validity and implications of Street Epistemology. Cameron defends the need for rational justification in belief while Pasco argues for an empathetic approach to discussions about faith, emphasizing the exploration of how beliefs are formed rather than just the content of those beliefs.

The Methodology of Street Epistemology

Pasco defines Street Epistemology as a method that examines how people acquire their beliefs rather than merely arguing whether those beliefs are true. He discusses the technique of asking questions to encourage individuals to reconsider their reasons for belief. Cameron articulates skepticism towards the method, arguing it may lead to misunderstandings about the complexity of faith.

The Debate on Properly Basic Beliefs

A core part of the argument revolves around the concept of properly basic beliefs as proposed by Alvin Plantinga. Cameron asserts that belief in God can be considered a properly basic belief that does not require evidence. Pasco challenges this by illustrating that even properly basic beliefs can have defeaters, indicating the necessity of evidential support in belief systems.

Concluding Thoughts on Street Epistemology

The podcast concludes with a discussion about the implications of Street Epistemology in faith conversations. While both men acknowledge a potential for effective engagement, they express concerns over the motivations behind Street Epistemology. Cameron perceives it as potentially manipulative, while Pasco expresses a commitment to genuine dialogue.

Show notes

Street Epistemology has become popular among many atheists as a conversational way to interrogate people's spiritual beliefs. Popularised by atheist philosopher Peter Boghossian in his book "A Manual For Creating Atheists" the movement is now seeking to create 10,000 street evangelists for atheism.

Pascoe Rapacci engages regularly in Street Epistemology (though doesn't claim to speak for the movement as a whole). He engages with Christian apologist Cameron Bertuzzi of Capturing Christianity on whether Street Epistemology is a valid way of investigating the truth of people's beliefs.

For Street Epistemology: https://streetepistemology.com/

For Pascoe Rapacci: https://www.twitter.com/pocketpasc

For Cameron Bertuzzi's written dialogue with a Street Epistemologist: http://capturingchristianity.com/conversation-street-epistemologist/

Get signed copies of Unbelievable? the book and audiobook: www.unbelievablebook.co.uk

Get Unbelievable? the Conference 2017 DVD/CD & Digital Download: http://www.premier.org.uk/shop

For more faith debates visit http://www.premierchristianradio.com/Shows/Saturday/Unbelievable

Join the conversation: Facebook and Twitter

Get the MP3 Podcast of Unbelievable? Via RSS or Via Itunes