Why I became a Protestant. Why I converted to Catholicism. Chris Arnzen & James Bogle

Key takeaways

The Reformation marked a significant dividing line in Christianity focused on issues of grace, works, and authority.
Chris Arnzen and James Bogle provide personal narratives that reflect broader theological debates between Catholicism and Protestantism.
Debate over salvation includes divergent views on faith alone versus the necessity of combining faith with works.
Historical doctrines within Christianity, particularly concerning Mary, remain a contentious issue between Catholic and Protestant perspectives.
Engagement and dialogue between differing Christian traditions can lead to greater understanding despite fundamental differences.

Summary

Introduction to the Reformation Discussions

The episode commemorates the 500th anniversary of the Reformation, featuring Justin Briley as the host. He discusses the significance of the Reformation and presents two guests, Chris Arnzen, who transitioned from Catholicism to Protestantism, and James Bogle, who moved from Anglicanism to Catholicism. The dialogue explores their reasons for these religious shifts and their perspectives on grace, works, and Catholic doctrines.

Chris Arnzen's Journey from Catholicism to Protestantism

Chris recounts his upbringing in a Roman Catholic family, sharing fond memories and experiences that initially shaped his faith. However, as a teenager, he began to question certain Catholic teachings after becoming disillusioned by responses he received from priests. Eventually, through friendships and encouragement from born-again Christians, he transitioned to Protestant faith, finding solace and truth in Reformed Baptist teachings. His story highlights crucial turning points, including his mother's supportive reaction to his conversion.

James Bogle's Conversion to Catholicism

In contrast, James shares his path toward embracing Catholicism. Growing up in a Protestant Anglican background, he often felt a lack of depth in his faith but initially believed in God. His intellectual journey began during university when he encountered a Catholic friend who answered his questions about the faith. After two years of exploration and debate, James found the Catholic Church’s doctrine to be the true continuation of Christian teachings, intertwining heart and mind in faith.

Debate on Grace, Works, and Salvation

The core of the discussion revolves around salvation, grace, and the role of works. Chris emphasizes justification by faith alone, arguing that Catholic doctrines add unnecessary works to salvation. In contrast, James argues that works are a necessary response to faith, pointing to biblical references that support the idea of cooperating with grace. They delve into the differences represented in the Catholic Church's teachings versus Protestant beliefs, particularly emphasizing the implications of the Council of Trent.

Differences in Doctrines and Historical Perspectives

As the conversation progresses, both guests discuss historical doctrines, particularly regarding Mary and her role in salvation. Chris references the theological development of specific doctrines within Catholicism that he deems unbiblical. James counters by asserting the historical continuity and spiritual significance of these doctrines, highlighting the authority of the Catholic Church in defining them. They also debate the implications of individual understanding of Scripture against the backdrop of the Church’s role in interpretation.

Conclusion and Reflection

The program wraps up with both guests acknowledging the validity of each other's beliefs while firmly standing by their respective positions. Chris expresses his concerns about the Catholic Church's teachings based on scriptural interpretations, while James reflects on the depth of faith within the Catholic tradition. The dialogue underscores a shared desire for truth, even amid doctrinal disagreements.

Show notes

To mark the 500th anniversary of The Reformation, Justin interviews two converts. One left his Catholic background for Reformed Baptist faith, the other went from Anglican to staunch Catholic.

Chris Arnzen and James Bogle explain why they traded places and debate why they each think they stand on the right side of the Reformation's dividing lines concerning grace, works and Catholic doctrines. Read their stories https://www.premierchristianity.com/Past-Issues/2017/October-2017/Trading-Places

For a free sample copy of Premier Christianity magazine's Reformation special: www.premierchristianity.com/freesample

For Chris Arnzen: http://www.ironsharpensironradio.com/

For James Bogle: http://catholicunion.org.uk/2013/11/james-bogle-vice-chairman/

Get signed copies of Unbelievable? the book and audiobook: www.unbelievablebook.co.uk

Get Unbelievable? the Conference 2017 DVD/CD & Digital Download: http://www.premier.org.uk/shop

For more faith debates visit http://www.premierchristianradio.com/Shows/Saturday/Unbelievable

Join the conversation: Facebook and Twitter

Get the MP3 Podcast of Unbelievable? Via RSS or Via Itunes