Pope Save America

Key takeaways

Cardinal Robert Prevost, the new Pope, is seen as a progressive voice against Trump-style immigration policies, igniting discussions about the impact of religious leadership on political debates.
Trump's trade deal with the UK is criticized for its insignificance and potential economic repercussions, illustrating the complexities of his administration's trade policies.
The nominations of Jeanine Pirro and Casey Means reflect a troubling trend of appointing controversial figures to key positions, raising concerns about their qualifications.
Constitutional rights regarding immigration are under scrutiny as Trump's administration continues to push policies that clash with traditional legal frameworks.
President Biden's public efforts to improve his reputation may not resonate with voters, highlighting the need for Democratic leaders to confront issues around leadership and cognitive competence.
Leah Litman's insights reveal how the Supreme Court's trajectory is shaped by conservative political goals, emphasizing the importance of understanding the current judicial climate.

Summary

The Appointment of a 'Woke Pope'

The podcast kicks off with the introduction of Cardinal Robert Prevost as Pope Leo XIV, the first American pope. Favreau and Pfeiffer discuss Prevost's progressive stance on various issues, particularly immigration, which aligns more with a humanitarian view compared to Trump's hardline policies. They humorously dissect the reactions from the right, particularly focusing on how the announcement has upset conservative circles, with references to social media responses and the irony of Trump's potential claim to fame.

Trump's Trade Deal with the UK

The hosts transition to discussing Trump's recent trade deal with the UK, highlighting the mixed reception and its implications. They emphasize the superficial nature of the deal, critiquing its lack of substantial changes to tariffs and the economic impact it may have. There's a humorous critique of Trump’s economic understanding and the potential consequences of ongoing trade wars, particularly with China, as the episode dives deep into the economic landscape under Trump’s administration.

MAGA’s Nomination Controversies

The podcast also delves into the nomination of Judge Jeanine Pirro for US Attorney and Casey Means as Surgeon General. They share concerns over the qualifications and backgrounds of these nominees, addressing the implications of appointing individuals with controversial reputations to significant legal positions. The hosts express skepticism about the political motivations behind these choices and how they reflect the broader agenda of Trump’s administration.

Due Process and Immigration Issues

A substantial discussion revolves around the constitutional rights related to immigration, framed through the lens of recent court decisions and testimonies from government officials. They challenge statements made by officials regarding due process rights for immigrants, emphasizing the legal ramifications of the Trump administration's immigration policies and practices, which often flout established norms and protections.

Biden's Image Rehabilitation Efforts

The conversation shifts to President Biden’s attempts to rehabilitate his image, particularly through appearances on platforms like The View. They analyze the effectiveness of these efforts in light of Biden's declining popularity and the necessary honesty for Democratic leaders about Biden's cognitive state and leadership capabilities. The hosts reflect on the implications of Biden's strategies for the upcoming election cycle.

Interview with Leah Litman

In the latter half of the episode, Jon interviews Leah Litman about her book Lawless, which addresses the Supreme Court's current trajectory under conservative influence. They discuss the politics behind the court's decisions, the implications of the current judicial philosophy, and how Trump's administration has affected the legal landscape in America. Litman provides insights into the historical context of the court's politicization and the underlying conservative grievances that drive modern judicial decision-making.

Show notes

White smoke! Cardinal Robert Prevost, an American-born prelate with a surprisingly political Twitter history, dons the papal vestments as Pope Leo XIV. Trump announces a trade deal with the United Kingdom and swaps out two key nominees for MAGA (and MAHA) favorites: tree-loving influencer Casey Means for Surgeon General, and Fox News’s Jeanine Pirro for US Attorney for DC. Senate Democrats clash with Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and FBI Director Kash Patel over the constitutional right to due process. And President Joe Biden attempts to rehabilitate his reputation, going on The View to talk about why he believes he would've won the 2024 election. Jon and Dan discuss MAGA's reaction to our new, possibly woke pope, House Republicans' internal debate over Medicaid cuts, and why Democrats should be honest about Biden's decline. Then, Jon talks to Leah Litman, co-host of Strict Scrutiny, about the Trump administration's attacks on the judicial system and her new book Lawless: How the Supreme Court Runs on Conservative Grievance, Fringe Theories, and Bad Vibes.

For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.