Is 'Gentle Parenting' Ruining French Children?

Key takeaways

French parenting traditionally emphasizes rules, discipline, and shaping children to integrate into society while allowing some autonomy.
The positive parenting movement, inspired by American practices, has gained traction in France, promoting empathy, understanding, and less authoritarian discipline methods.
There is significant pushback from French experts and policymakers against this permissive approach, leading to public debates and new regulations against educational violence.
The controversy reflects larger societal questions about the role of children, societal support systems, and cultural values surrounding parenthood.
Parents are navigating a complex landscape of contradictory advice, emphasizing the importance of trusting personal instincts and considering societal context when choosing parenting styles.

Summary

The Debate Over French vs. American Parenting Styles

This section explores the traditional image of French parenting as strict, rule-based, and focused on discipline, with a strong emphasis on children adhering to societal norms through routines like set bedtimes and structured meals. It introduces the influence of Pamela Druckerman's book 'Bringing Up Baby,' which popularized the idea that French parents manage to raise well-behaved children without sacrificing their own freedom. A contrast is drawn between the highly structured French approach and the more permissive, child-centric American style of positive and gentle parenting, which emphasizes empathy, understanding, and giving children more autonomy.

The Rise of Positive Parenting in France and Its Pushback

This section discusses the recent emergence of positive parenting practices in France, imported mainly from English-speaking countries, and their growing popularity facilitated by social media. It highlights key figures like Caroline Goldman and Isabelle Fioza, who advocate for gentle, empathetic methods over traditional rules, including the use of long timeouts and reframing discipline through understanding children's feelings. It also covers the backlash from French experts and government policies, such as the 2019 law against educational violence, which many see as a move against permissive or overly empathetic parenting.

Cultural and Societal Impacts of Parenting Debates

This part delves into the broader societal implications of the parenting controversy, including how it reflects changing perceptions of children's roles in society and societal value for parenthood itself. The debate points to a tension between societal support and individual parenting choices, with French society grappling with declining birth rates and changing attitudes towards parenting. It also touches on international comparisons, particularly with Sweden, where public life for children is more visible and parental happiness appears higher, contrasting with the stressed and divided French parental landscape.

Personal Reflection and Future of Parenting in France

The final section features Madeleine Schwartz’s personal insights as someone raised between American and French cultures and now living as a parent in France. She emphasizes the importance of trusting one’s own instincts amid conflicting advice and highlights the role of societal infrastructure and support in shaping parenting experiences. The discussion underscores the complexity of modern parenting and the ongoing search for the 'best' method amid cultural shifts and societal pressures.

Show notes

“Traditional” French parenting is built on a foundation of firm boundaries, strictness and punishment for misbehavior. Within these rules, children are also allowed freedom and autonomy, which some say results in both well-behaved children and stress-free parents.

In recent years, though, American-style “gentle” or “positive” parenting has gained a toehold in the country, unsettling decades of orthodoxy about the best way to raise a French child. It has prompted a fierce debate, with both sides accusing the other of being harmful.

In today’s episode, Madeleine Schwartz, a journalist who lives in Paris, talks with Michael Barbaro about the dispute over parenting styles in France and what it says about the eternal search for the “right” way to raise children.

On Today’s Episode:

Madeleine Schwartz is a journalist and editor in Paris.

Background Reading:

Did American-Style ‘Gentle Parenting’ Spoil French Children?

Art Credit: Illustration by Kimberly Elliott

For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.