Fresh Air

'Mississippi is a reflection of the nation': Scott Colom's historic win

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • Colom’s victory was made possible by organized, data-driven turnout across Mississippi, not simply by a symbolic backlash against Hyde-Smith.
  • The campaign’s humor and cultural specificity allowed Colom to speak across racial and generational boundaries while addressing the material issue of rising food costs.
  • Glaude argues that Mississippi is not an isolated example of American failure; its racial, economic, and political contradictions reflect choices made by the entire country.
  • Lehman and Glaude say that excluding Black political power from education distorts both Black children’s sense of possibility and the wider society’s understanding of justice.
  • The Medgar Evers advertisement presented Colom’s election as part of an unfinished historical struggle rather than an inexplicable political miracle.
  • The guests expect Colom to remain accountable to Mississippi organizers and to protect the state’s vulnerable children while resisting Washington’s pressures.

Summary

Colom’s win became a historic Mississippi reversal

Host Tanya Mosley introduces Democrat Scott Colom’s defeat of Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi’s Senate race. Colom, a seventh-generation Mississippian descended from an enslaved woman, will become the state’s first Black U.S. senator in nearly 150 years, following Hiram Revels’s 1870 service during Reconstruction. The victory is especially striking because Hyde-Smith had blocked Colom’s nomination for a federal judgeship three years earlier. Mosley frames the result against Mississippi’s history: Black political power was built after the Civil War, violently dismantled, and followed by generations of migration out of the state to escape Jim Crow and racial terror.

Organizers turned redistricting anxiety into electoral math

Eddie Glaude says he began believing Colom could win after attending a Jackson march organized under “All Roads Lead to the South,” following a threatened redistricting effort. NAACP leader Derek Johnson brought him to the event, where he saw young and older organizers counting the votes needed in DeSoto, Holmes, Jackson County, and Hinds County rather than merely longing for the civil-rights movement of the past. Glaude says the infrastructure was ready, and that Colom was a “political athlete” who could harness Black voters’ full power and undermine the math behind Republican gerrymandering. He left thinking, “We’re about to shock the world up in here.”

The campaign’s irreverent style mobilized new voters

Kiese Lehman contrasts Colom’s campaign with Mike Espy’s 2018 challenge to Hyde-Smith. Espy had been treated as a “clean, electable Democrat,” while Colom removed what Lehman calls the cloak of political respectability. Lehman says he recognized Colom’s potential after seeing the “pick another protein” ad and believed the candidate had both the votes and the cultural force to prevent Republicans from overturning a close result. The campaign brought together older voters who had learned to present a carefully respectable image with young people in hoodies, facial piercings, and earrings. Lehman calls it not merely intergenerational but “intercultural” mobilization.

“Pick another protein” made inflation culturally legible

Hyde-Smith had responded to rising beef prices by telling consumers they had many proteins to choose from and should “pick another protein.” Colom’s ad answered, “I’d rather pick another senator instead,” surrounded by Mississippians saying she had “lost her damn mind.” Lehman says the ad made Colom the viewer: a young white man, an older Black woman eating catfish, and an older white woman shopping for unaffordable food all react as ordinary viewers would, while Colom watches and laughs with them. Glaude says the humor’s Mississippi cadence crossed racial lines, but the ad also attacked Hyde-Smith’s absence and failure to address the state’s cost-of-living pressures.

Hyde-Smith’s public-hanging remark embodied fear and humiliation

Mosley revisits a 2020 campaign stop where Hyde-Smith praised a supporter by saying that if he invited her to a public hanging, she would be in the front row. Hyde-Smith called it a figure of speech and still won. Lehman says the literal words evoked premature death and killing, while politically giving voters the fear and anger they wanted. Living in Mississippi at the time, he felt humiliated and angry that the nation’s Blackest state would elect a senator who made that statement. He also believed she would win again, which made Colom’s eventual victory difficult for him to process.

Glaude says Mississippi concentrates the country’s contradictions

Asked what Mississippi had figured out, Glaude cautions against treating the election as proof that the state’s problems are solved. He says the victory feels bigger to him than Barack Obama’s election because Mississippi is a closed society where beautiful landscapes and gracious people coexist with violence, poverty, and “organized elites who have seized government.” Its history, race relations, and economic struggles offer a telescoped view of America. Colom’s own post-election remarks make the same point: the country permitted Mississippi’s loss of Black voting rights and Jim Crow. Glaude says Mississippi reflects national choices rather than standing apart from them.

Revels’s overlooked history shaped what the guests learned

A Saturday Night Live sketch joked that Hiram Revels, the first Black senator, has no national holiday, statue, or Jay-Z song. Lehman learned about Revels because his mother, a Jackson State scholar of Mississippi law and public policy, made him research him after he discovered the figure was absent from his 1980s encyclopedias. Glaude had a different education: his mother worked at Ingalls Shipyard and his father was a postman, while a teacher presented the Civil War through a Lost Cause framework that left him admiring Stonewall Jackson. He did not encounter Revels substantively until Morehouse. Both examples show how Black political power can disappear from the stories children are taught.

The stories a society omits limit its sense of possibility

Glaude argues that histories do more than record the past: what a society includes or excludes shapes the people it believes itself capable of becoming. Leaving out Black power, including Revels’s example, produces gaps that deform judgment, empathy, and character, affecting both the children denied the full story and the people doing the denying. Lehman extends the idea to language. “Make America Great Again,” “Black Lives Matter,” and Colom’s “pick another senator” are sentences that can organize movements and open possibilities. As an English professor, he says people must treat sentences as consequential constructions that can be challenged, revised, and redirected.

The Medgar Evers ad connected Colom to unfinished history

Colom’s closing advertisement moved from comedy to a detailed account of Medgar Evers’s home, where Evers’s children were taught to crawl to the bathroom if they heard gunfire. The ad recalled Evers’s service in Normandy, his voter-registration work, his 1963 assassination, two failed juries, and the 1994 conviction secured after his widow Myrlie kept pursuing the case. Lehman says the ad connected Colom’s governing identity to Black activists who made his candidacy possible, while Glaude reads it through Faulkner’s “the past is never dead; it’s not even past.” The ad asked voters to use their ballots in honor of those who died for voting rights.

The guests expect accountability, protection, and independence

Because Colom won by only 8,031 votes, Lehman says his safety and that of his wife Nadia and children must be taken seriously. He hopes Colom protects all Mississippi children, including queer, poor, and trans children, while Glaude hopes he brings Mississippi’s distinctive moral perspective to Washington rather than yielding to the “siren song” of national power. Both want organizers such as Cassandra Welchlin, Rekia Lumumba, and Sister Lambright Haynes to hold him accountable. Lehman also hopes Democrats learn to follow and fund the people’s vision. Glaude adds that Black voters are not cattle to be herded every two or four years: they are a constituency with concrete interests.

Sponsors

  • Capella University · Capella promotes its FlexPath learning format, which lets students earn a degree at their own pace without putting life on pause.
  • Sony Pictures Classics · The ad promotes Pedro Almodóvar’s film Bitter Christmas, described as two colorful stories set 20 years apart and exploring the relationships between reality, fiction, inspiration, and life. It was playing in New York and Los Angeles and would open nationwide November 25.
  • NPR's Newsmakers · A promo for an episode featuring conservative media co-founder Ben Shapiro discussing his regret over the president’s performance, while not regretting his vote, and the future of right-wing media and the Republican Party.
  • Sports in America with David Green · The weekly WHYY and PRX podcast features conversations with athletes, coaches, parents, and fans about the personal and transformative experiences surrounding sports.
  • Thumbtack · Thumbtack says users can upload a photo or voice note and use AI-powered search to find a highly rated local professional for a home project.
  • The Pulse · WHYY’s weekly health-and-science podcast explores questions including intuition, electric-car sounds, diagnosis, and fungal communication.
  • Bombas · Bombas promotes socks, slippers, shoes, and other gifts, offering 20% off with the code NPR.

Show notes

Scott Colom's Senate victory in Mississippi surprised much of the country. A Democrat, he defeated the Republican incumbent in a deeply Republican state, becoming Mississippi's first Black U.S. senator in nearly 150 years. But for scholars Eddie Glaude and Kiese Laymon, who both grew up in Mississippi, the significance of this moment goes far beyond politics. Glaude says, “To me, this is bigger than Barack Obama's election.” They spoke with Tonya Mosley about Mississippi's complicated political history, and the significance of the win for the rest of America. 

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter 
Follow us on Instagram 
Subscribe to our YouTube channel 
Check out the Fresh Air Archives

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file