Fresh Air

John Lithgow

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • John Lithgow said playing Roald Dahl required understanding the personal pain behind his cruelty without excusing the antisemitism that contaminated his arguments.
  • Giant deliberately delays Dahl’s most hateful statements so audiences must wrestle with the difference between criticizing Israeli policy and condemning Jewish people before seeing his darkest side.
  • Lithgow attributed Churchill’s distinctive voice in The Crown partly to silicone mouth “plumpers,” after an experiment with apple balls left him spitting cider over the rehearsal table.
  • Lithgow’s acting career began after a highly mobile childhood in regional theater and accelerated at Harvard, where he quickly became a prominent extracurricular actor.
  • He valued Third Rock from the Sun because its live studio audience produced genuine laughter, allowing television to preserve theater’s immediate connection between performers and spectators.
  • Lithgow said performing for children was rewarding because children suspend disbelief more completely than adults and respond with uninhibited enthusiasm.

Summary

Lithgow finds Dahl’s cruelty behind his success

Dave Davies introduced John Lithgow as an actor with nearly 200 stage, film, and television performances, including his Tony-winning portrayal of Roald Dahl in Giant. Lithgow said actors must find a way to empathize with even scoundrels by asking what made them that way. He was intrigued that Dahl, enormously valuable to publishers, was fired by Alfred A. Knopf for being cruel and impossible to work with. Lithgow also knew this side of Dahl through his friend Maria Tucci, widow of editor Robert Gottlieb, who had fired Dahl.

Giant stages Dahl’s antisemitic controversy as a debate

Lithgow explained that Giant is set in 1983 around Dahl’s 1982 review of a book about Israel’s invasion of Lebanon and the PLO’s expulsion from Beirut. The review strongly took the Palestinians’ side but also exposed Dahl’s antisemitism, threatening sales of his forthcoming book The Witches. Representatives from Farrar, Straus and Giroux and Jonathan Cape try to make Dahl apologize, but he refuses. The first act withholds his most explicit words, letting audiences consider whether he is criticizing Israeli policy or condemning Jews; the argument becomes a passionate exchange with a young American Jewish publisher representative.

Dahl’s personal tragedies do not excuse his hatred

Lithgow said Dahl’s arguments can occasionally be correct, but they are “polluted by anti-Semitism,” making him “like a broken clock.” The play builds toward an explicitly hateful remark that made audiences audibly gasp, and Lithgow’s challenge was to motivate that moment emotionally as well as politically. He found a possible route through Dahl’s painful history: outsider status as a Norwegian Welsh schoolboy, the deaths of his father and sister, brutal school beatings, a nearly fatal RAF crash, his wife Patricia Neal’s strokes, his infant son’s brain injury after a taxi accident, and his daughter’s death from measles. Lithgow saw a man angry at life who could not resist tormenting others.

Giant feels newly relevant during the Gaza conflict

Davies noted that Giant was being performed amid bitter arguments over Israeli military actions in Gaza following Hamas’s October 7 attack, echoing the play’s setting during conflict involving Israel, Lebanon, and the PLO. Lithgow said audiences repeatedly called the play astonishingly timely because lines written about events 40 years earlier seemed to describe the present, including discussion of missiles and raids by Hezbollah forces in Lebanon. Davies also noted that Dahl’s family apologized for his antisemitism on its website in 2020; Lithgow emphasized that Dahl himself never apologized.

Lithgow made Churchill sound unlike himself

Discussing The Crown, Lithgow recalled being intimidated by Winston Churchill’s status as a figure whom nearly every English person can imitate or quote. He accepted Peter Morgan and Stephen Daldry’s offer despite being American, then learned Daldry had partly cast him because Churchill’s mother was American. Lithgow believed his American energy enlivened the English character. To reproduce Churchill’s distinctive lisp, he first tried apple balls carved with a melon baller, which filled his mouth with cider; tooth maker Christopher Lyons instead created silicone “plumpers” that clipped onto his back teeth and transformed his voice and physical feeling.

Dumbledore suits an actor who now plays old men

Lithgow had completed his work as Dumbledore in HBO’s Harry Potter series, whose first season was still filming for another month when he spoke. Production compressed his scenes so he could perform Giant on Broadway, making his final month brutal and aging him. Davies asked whether learning lines had become harder at 80. Lithgow said memorizing is more difficult and both his brain and body are tired, but once lines are in place he is fine. He joked that he keeps getting cast as “broken down old men,” so he gets better cast every year.

A childhood of regional theaters led Lithgow to acting

Lithgow described a mobile childhood after his father, initially an Antioch College professor, created a summer Shakespeare festival and eventually became a professional theater manager. Between sixth grade and high-school graduation, Lithgow lived in roughly eight places as his father ran Shakespeare festivals and later Princeton’s McCarter Theater. He discovered acting seriously at Harvard, where he was cast within two weeks as Reverend Anderson in The Devil’s Disciple and became a campus star. He also directed, designed, staged a ballet, and directed two Mozart operas before studying at London’s LAMDA. His two years there unintentionally gave him an English accent that his sister found pretentious.

Third Rock captured live audience laughter

Lithgow recalled Third Rock from the Sun, which ran from 1996 to 2001 and followed four aliens learning how to inhabit human bodies and interpret human behavior. In the opening scene, the aliens mistake a couple making out in a nearby car for people cleaning one another. Lithgow said the show’s comedy became more sophisticated as the characters became more human; Joseph Gordon-Levitt was only 13 when he joined the cast. Because episodes were prepared over four days and performed Tuesday nights before a live audience, the actors treated it as a point of honor to generate real laughter rather than use canned laughter, sometimes sustaining audience laughter for 15 or 20 seconds.

Roberta Muldoon became Lithgow’s Oscar-nominated breakthrough

In The World According to Garp, Lithgow played Roberta Muldoon, a transgender former Philadelphia Eagles tight end, opposite Robin Williams. Lithgow loved the character from John Irving’s novel, but director George Roy Hill initially rejected him as too tall and feared he would look comical beside Williams. After the production considered athletes, transgender women, and many actors for eight months, Lithgow returned, screen-tested in drag, and drew on Jan Morris’s memoir Conundrum to improvise Roberta’s experience. Hill found him convincing, and the performance earned Lithgow an Oscar nomination. Lithgow also recalled enjoying his contrasting role as a purportedly frail, psychotic killer in Blowout.

Children’s concerts gave Lithgow real suspension of disbelief

Lithgow said writing nine children’s picture books, recording three children’s albums, and performing with major orchestras became a second career over roughly 15 years. He was not doing it for money; he enjoyed the ecstatic response of children, who, unlike adults, completely suspend disbelief. In interactive concerts, he drew animals on a large easel while children shouted guesses, then sang “Mud, Mud, Glorious Mud” after they identified a hippo. He compared his constant stream of unfinished creative ideas to a physics-class static-electricity dome, saying some ideas may also reflect fear that no one will hire him to act. He described his grandchildren, ranging from 20 to eight months, as another source of joy.

Justin Chang finds Elsinore moving but overworked

Film critic Justin Chang reviewed Elsinore, in which Andrew Scott plays Scottish actor Ian Charlson preparing to perform Hamlet at London’s National Theatre in 1989 while living with AIDS. Charlson takes the role after Daniel Day-Lewis leaves the production, despite Dr. Margaret Johnson’s warnings that rehearsals will damage his health; he tells her he wants quality of life rather than quantity. Derek Jarman criticizes Charlson for not publicly discussing his sexuality, while Scott’s casting gives added significance to the role. Chang praised Scott’s performance but said the film, directed by Simon Stone and written by Stephen Beresford, relies on clumsy montages and plays like an extended trailer.

I Play Rocky turns Stallone’s struggle into a predictable underdog story

Chang described I Play Rocky as a crowd-pleasing account of a broke young Sylvester Stallone, played by Anthony Ippolito, trying to establish himself as an actor and writer. The film includes his near-eviction, a stray dog, a softcore porn job, an unsupportive father, and support from girlfriend and future wife Sasha. Stallone writes Rocky in three and a half days after the 1975 Muhammad Ali–Chuck Wepner fight, then refuses to sell the script to United Artists unless he plays the lead. Chang enjoyed the producer negotiations and praised Ippolito’s resemblance to Stallone, but found the film formulaic because Rocky’s eventual Best Picture victory feels inevitable.

Sponsors

  • GiveWell · GiveWell describes itself as a research and grant-making organization focused on finding cost-effective ways to help save and improve lives. Listeners were invited to learn more or make a tax-deductible donation, selecting podcast and NPR at checkout.
  • Easy Cater · Easy Cater helps organizations order food for meetings and events from favorite restaurants, set up employee meal programs, manage food spending, meet dietary needs, and use flexible payment options with 24/7 customer support.
  • Leesa · Leesa advertised its lineup of mattresses, offering up to 30% off mattresses plus an extra $50 off with promo code NPR.
  • U.S. Bank · U.S. Bank promoted Business Essentials, a combination of no-monthly-maintenance-fee checking and card-payment processing. Deposit products were identified as being offered by U.S. Bank National Association, member FDIC.

Show notes

Actor John Lithgow talks with Dave Davies about some of his iconic roles, including Winston Churchill in The Crown and controversial children's book author Roald Dahl in the play “Giant.” He plays Dumbledore in a new HBO Harry Potter series.

Film critic Justin Chang reviews Elsinore and I Play Rocky. 


See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file