Square: Jim McKelvey. He Lost a $2,000 Sale, Then Built a $10 Billion Company

Key takeaways

Entrepreneurial success often rises from moments of frustration and personal experience.
Understanding the regulations and challenges of your industry can create strategic opportunities.
Innovative thinking can solve complex problems, sometimes by leveraging existing technology in new ways.
Transparency and honesty can create stronger bonds with investors and partners.
Staying focused on innovation is key to surviving and thriving in a competitive market.
Using resources and experience to address larger systemic issues reflects a true entrepreneurial spirit.

Summary

The Birth of Square

Jim McKelvey shares the story of how Square was born out of a moment of frustration when he lost a $2,000 sale due to the inability to accept American Express credit cards. This experience led him to realize the market's need for a simple, accessible credit card payment solution, which ultimately laid the groundwork for Square's development.

Navigating Regulatory Challenges

Jim discusses the complex regulatory landscape Square had to navigate in order to enter the payments industry. He emphasizes that existing systems often protect monopolies and make it difficult for newcomers to compete. This 'regulatory capture' impacted a number of industries, including banking.

Innovative Use of Technology

The episode highlights how Jim and Jack Dorsey decided to use the headphone jack on the iPhone for their credit card reader to bypass Apple's restrictions, illustrating a clever hack to solve a complex problem. By creating a simple and portable reader, Square was able to empower small businesses.

Investor Pitch Strategy

Jim reveals his unconventional pitch strategy where he openly shared the 140 reasons why their business could fail instead of exaggerating its potential. This candor shifted the atmosphere in the room and resonated with investors, leading to several backing offers.

Against All Odds: Competing with Amazon

As Square grew, it faced fierce competition from Amazon entering the payment processing space. Rather than engage in a price war, Square remained focused on innovation, which ultimately secured its market position despite Amazon's attempts to undercut their services.

Looking Ahead: Future Endeavors

Post-Square, Jim has continued to tackle various challenges, including drug testing efficiency, indicating a focus on solving big problems using his resources and experiences garnered from building Square.

Show notes

Most entrepreneurs think the hardest part of building a company is the product.
For Jim McKelvey — co-founder of Square — the hardest part was the system around the product.
Because Square wasn’t just competing with other startups …
It was competing with regulations, middlemen, entrenched networks, and monopolies designed to keep outsiders out.
In this episode, Jim shares the mindset and tactics that helped Square go from a tiny card reader that processed credit card payments … to a company—now known as Block— that generates over $10 billion in gross profit.
What You’ll Learn:

Why the market is often “locked” on purpose

How a simple hack can solve a seemingly complex problem

How candor can sway investors more than confidence

How Square survived by building something Amazon couldn’t copy

Timestamps:

00:10:01 – Engineering and art: Balancing an IBM job with glassblowing

00:13:21 – The family trauma that rewired Jim

00:34:01 – Losing a $2,000 sale — the moment Square was born

00:38:26 – Breaking into the credit card club: “We were violating 17 rules”

00:43:51 – The headphone jack hack that sidestepped Apple’s control

00:53:23 – The “140 reasons we might fail” pitch that won over investors

01:00:16 – The taxi ride that convinced Jim he had product-market fit

01:03:18 – Amazon attacks, and why copying doesn’t always work

01:07:08 – The founder’s job after success: choosing hard problems

***
Hey—want to be a guest on HIBT?
If you’re building a business, why not get advice from some of the greatest entrepreneurs on Earth?
Every Thursday on the HIBT Advice Line, a previous HIBT guest helps new entrepreneurs work through the challenges they’re facing right now. Advice that’s smart, actionable, and absolutely free.
Just call 1-800-433-1298, leave a message, and you may soon get guidance from someone who started where you did, and went on to build something massive.
So—give us a call. We can’t wait to hear what you’re working on.
***
This episode was produced by Alex Cheng with music composed by Ramtin Arablouei. It was edited by Neva Grant with research help from Katherine Sypher. Our engineers were Patrick Murray and Robert Rodriguez.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices