How I Built This with Guy Raz

Beautycounter: Gregg Renfrew. She Built Beautycounter to $1B… Then Got Fired From Her Own Company

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • Building a movement is more impactful than just creating a product. Engaging communities and creating shared values can lead to stronger loyalty and success.
  • Growth at all costs can be dangerous. Markets fluctuate, and overexpansion without proper control can lead to failure.
  • Direct sales, done right, can outperform traditional DTC methods by fostering trust and personal connections.
  • The emotional toll of losing control over a business, especially one's own creation, can be profound but can also lead to valuable lessons and new beginnings.
  • Rebuilding after setbacks requires humility, a clear vision, and the willingness to start anew, often from scratch.

Summary

Greg Renfrew’s Entrepreneurial Journey and Early Business Ventures

Greg Renfrew's career began with selling Xerox copiers, experiencing the challenges of door-to-door sales and the realization early on that perseverance is key. Her first notable business was an online wedding registry, inspired by her observations of the wedding gift process and her time in London. She innovated by integrating online purchasing with a bespoke service, partnering with prestigious British brands, and raising capital during the dot-com boom. This venture grew rapidly, reaching hundreds of millions in revenue, but was undone by the collapse of the dot-com bubble, illustrating the risks of 'growth at all costs.' Her sale to Martha Stewart marked a high point, but also exposed her to new challenges in the corporate world.

The Birth of Beauty Counter and the Challenge of 'Clean Beauty'

Greg noticed a significant gap in the beauty industry for high-performance, safe, and environmentally friendly products. At that time, 'clean beauty' was not a defined term, and creating products void of harmful chemicals was a radical idea. She emphasized the complexity of defining 'clean' and aimed to set new industry standards. Her strategy involved building a community of women as brand ambassadors through direct sales, leveraging trust and personal recommendation, which helped grow the brand rapidly. The model focused on education, community-building, and product performance, scaling to hundreds of millions in sales.

Growth Challenges and Corporate Restructuring

Despite rapid growth and significant investment, including an $80 million raise from VCs and private equity, Greg faced difficulties as the business navigated post-pandemic uncertainties and market shifts. The company struggled with pandemic-related disruptions, COVID variants, and changing consumer habits. This led to pressure from investors, ultimately resulting in her being ousted as CEO in October 2021, despite her ownership stake. The relationship with new leadership was strained, and internal struggles compounded the company's difficulties, culminating in assets being foreclosed and a takeover by the bank.

Acquisition and Relaunch of Counter

In a surprising turn, Greg acquired her company's assets out of foreclosure on short notice, driven by her passion and belief in the brand’s mission. She decided to rebuild the business from scratch, emphasizing transparency and authenticity. The new Counter brand maintained a multi-channel strategy including e-commerce, community-focused brand ambassadors, and selective retail partnerships, with an emphasis on clear, meaningful 'clean' standards. Greg's journey highlights resilience, adaptability, and her ongoing commitment to the movement for safer, better beauty products.

Sponsors

  • How I Built This · Follow How I Built This on Instagram, X, Facebook, and subscribe to Guy Raz's newsletter for insights from entrepreneurs.

Show notes

Gregg Renfrew started a movement by making better-for-you cosmetics, then enlisted an army of women to build the business through direct sales. But after selling Beautycounter, she was pushed out of the company she created.
Then she got to do something almost no founder gets to do: 
She bought her company back. Then lost it again. Then took the risky step of rebuilding it into a new brand, now called Counter.  
This is a story about ambition, humility, and second chances.  
Gregg learned her first lessons by launching an early online wedding registry and selling it to Martha Stewart. She briefly led a clothing company and was summarily fired— by messenger.
In this candid conversation, Gregg talks about the bold innovation she brought to the beauty industry, and the lessons she learned from working with difficult people—including, at times, herself. 

What You’ll Learn:
How to build a movement—not just a product
The hidden risks of “growth at all costs”
Why direct sales (done right) can outperform traditional DTC
The emotional toll of being fired from your own company
How to rebuild your identity after losing your business
What it takes to come back—and do it differently the second time

Timestamps:
(00:03:50) – Selling Xerox machines and getting doors slammed in her face
(00:05:44) – The early inspiration for an online wedding registry.
(00:14:19) – The brutal lesson of the dot-com crash: “growth at all costs”
(00:19:33) – Standing up to Martha Stewart: “I was cocky.” 
(00:21:25) – Getting fired as CEO… by messenger… in front of her team
(00:28:07) – The moment she realized the beauty industry had a massive gap
(00:30:45) – “Clean beauty didn’t exist”—and why that made it so hard
(00:42:24) – Building a 60,000-person sales force, scaling to hundreds of millions in sales
(00:46:40) – Selling Beautycounter for $1B… and losing control months later
(00:54:03) – The emotional aftermath of being pushed out—and what came next

This episode was produced by John Isabella with music composed by Ramtin Arablouei. It was edited by Neva Grant with research help from Noor Gill. Our engineers were Patrick Murray and Jimmy Keeley.

Follow How I Built This:
Instagram → @howibuiltthis
X → @HowIBuiltThis
Facebook → How I Built This
Follow Guy Raz:
Instagram → @guy.raz
Youtube → guy_raz
X → @guyraz
Substack → guyraz.substack.com
Website → guyraz.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file