Bobbie: Laura Modi. How a Baby Formula Startup Took Market Share From Two Industry Giants

Key takeaways

Innovation in highly regulated industries requires persistence, adaptability, and strategic thinking.
Building a community and sharing authentic stories can significantly support a startup's growth and acceptance.
Vertical integration and ownership of manufacturing facilities can reduce reliance on third-party producers and mitigate supply chain risks.
Regulatory challenges can be turned into opportunities for differentiation if addressed with transparency and compliance.
Challenging industry giants often involves resilience, bold decision-making, and a clear long-term vision for societal change.

Summary

The Inspiration and Founding of Bobby

Laura Modi, with her background in tech from Google and Airbnb, was motivated to create a better infant formula after experiencing difficulties with breastfeeding her own children. She noticed that the U.S. infant formula market was dominated by two large companies with standards that hadn't evolved since the 1980s, especially compared to Europe, which updated their standards much more frequently. Her realization that the existing industry was inadequate and outdated led her to start Bobby, emphasizing organic, modern, and transparent ingredients. The journey was fraught with regulatory hurdles, a public dispute with the FDA, and the challenge of manufacturing, but her determination and innovative approach helped her build the brand from a small startup into a significant player in the U.S. market.

Challenges in Regulatory Approval and Manufacturing

Laura faced significant regulatory challenges, including an initial FDA shutdown of her product because it appeared to be infant formula without proper approval. This setback led her to seek manufacturing partners outside the U.S., ultimately finding a family-run German company willing to produce her formula, which initially did not meet U.S. standards. A public recall and regulatory compliance issues followed, but Laura and her team adapted swiftly, acquiring their own manufacturing facility in Ohio to regain control and ensure quality. The process included navigating complex FDA approvals, supply chain adjustments, and strategic decisions around branding and product positioning, all while managing the risks of rapid growth and inventory challenges.

Growth, Market Strategy, and Industry Disruption

From launching sales in 2021 with a direct-to-consumer model, Bobby has experienced exponential growth, reaching hundreds of millions in sales and capturing nearly 4% of the U.S. infant formula market. The brand's strategy involved building a community among parents, emphasizing emotional storytelling, and positioning the product as European-style, high-quality formula. During the 2022 infant formula shortage caused by a major recall, Bobby surged in demand but faced supply constraints that led to tough decisions like temporarily halting new customer orders. Recognizing the risks of dependency on a single manufacturer, Laura shifted her focus toward vertical integration, acquiring a manufacturing plant in Ohio to better control supply and quality. Her larger vision includes advocating for policy change to improve the industry and challenging the dominance of the major players.

Leadership, Culture, and Future Vision

Laura highlights the importance of company culture, emphasizing the value of unconventional hires, particularly women, and building a resilient, mission-driven organization. Her long-term goal is to transform societal perceptions around infant feeding, reduce shame and stigma, and influence policy changes like expanding parental leave and WIC programs. She envisions Bobby as not just a brand but a movement to elevate the importance of quality, transparency, and emotional support for parents. Her drive is rooted in the real needs of families, and she aims for Bobby to become a household name, fostering a culture of trust, advocacy, and innovation in the industry.

Show notes

Laura Modi set out to build a better infant formula.
What followed was years of setbacks: a crippling dispute with the FDA, a frustrating search for a manufacturer, and the constant fear that the company would run out of money before it reached customers.
But today, Bobbie generates over $100 million a year and has captured nearly 4% of the U.S. infant formula market by challenging one of the most protected industries in America.
In this conversation, Laura explains how she made it through—and why many of the moments that looked like disasters ultimately built a better company, and made her a better entrepreneur.

You'll learn:

Why Laura left a great job to launch one of the most heavily regulated products in America

How she spent nearly $200,000 of her own savings before raising outside capital

How 64 investor pitches helped her tell a better story

How a public apology changed the trajectory of the company

Why Bobbie turned away thousands of customers during its fastest period of growth

Why Laura moved to Washington, D.C., and how she thinks about federal oversight

Timestamps:
10:52 – The emotional experience that revealed a massive business opportunity
20:44 – Laura learns about the two companies that had a lock on U.S. formula
23:27 – Quitting Airbnb, starting Bobbie while pregnant, risking her savings
34:12 – Pitching 64 investors—and the brutal feedback that fueled her to keep going
45:24 – The FDA shuts the company down after two weeks
56:34 – Building a community while waiting nearly two years for approval
1:03:01 – Launch day, and selling out faster than expected
1:07:49 – Why Laura shut off new customer orders during the infant formula shortage
1:11:02 – Buying her own manufacturing plant to control Bobbie's future
1:14:09 – Navigating Washington, regulation, and building a mission-driven brand

This episode was researched and produced by Alex Cheng with music by Ramtin Arablouei. It was edited by Neva Grant. Our audio engineer was Robert Rodriguez.

Follow How I Built This:
Instagram → @howibuiltthis
X → @HowIBuiltThis
Facebook → How I Built This

Follow Guy Raz:
Instagram → @guy.raz
Youtube → guy_raz
X → @guyraz
Substack → guyraz.substack.com
Website → guyraz.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices