The #1 Newsletter Metric You Need To Pay More Attention To

Key takeaways

Replies should be prioritized over open and click rates as they are a stronger signal of engagement and deliverability.
Welcome emails should focus on eliciting replies to help ensure future emails land in the reader's inbox.
Creating emotionally resonant content can lead to higher engagement rates and foster a deeper connection with readers.
Real-world examples can provide innovative strategies for increasing newsletter interactions and responses.
High reply rates can come with drawbacks, including increased unsubscribe rates, highlighting the need for a balanced approach.

Summary

The Importance of Replies Over Other Metrics

In this episode, Chanel and Dylan discuss why replies are the most crucial metric newsletter creators should focus on, even more than open or click rates. They explain how replies serve as a powerful signal of engagement and deliverability, emphasizing that mental health for creators can also benefit from receiving feedback like replies.

Tactics for Encouraging Replies

The hosts share practical strategies to increase replies, such as optimizing welcome emails to include a clear call-to-action for replies, sending pattern-interrupt emails, and creating content that resonates emotionally with readers. They outline how inviting more interaction can enhance both deliverability and engagement.

Engaging Content and Emotional Resonance

Chanel and Dylan explore the types of emotional responses that can elicit replies, referencing Shaan Puri's 7 key emotions framework. They note that content should evoke laughter, surprise, and curiosity, among other feelings, making newsletters more engaging and increasing the likelihood of reader responses.

Real-World Examples of Engaging Strategies

The episode highlights several successful strategies from well-known creators, such as Mario Gabriele's 'Puzzler,' Toby Howell's gamified email interaction, and Katelyn Bourgoin's interactive polls. These examples demonstrate diverse methods for boosting engagement through creativity and fun.

The Two Sides of High Reply Rates

While discussing the value of engagement, the hosts candidly address the downsides of encouraging more replies, including potential high unsubscribe rates. They share Chanel's experience with generating 200 replies but also facing the challenge of record unsubscribes, sparking a discussion on balancing reaction with audience retention.

Show notes

The Growth Vault is LIVE: Chenell's brand-new offer for newsletter creators is here—filled with newsletter templates, growth strategies, and real examples you can implement at your own pace.

--------------------------------------

“I sent this short email—and got over 200 replies—when I usually get maybe 8 to 15. It was wild." — Chenell

In this episode, we're digging into the art (and science) of getting more replies to your newsletter.

Why replies?

Because we believe (and we're not alone) that replies should be the #1 metric most newsletter creators should be focusing on—even more than open or click rates.

We unpack why replies are a powerful signal for deliverability, engagement—even creator mental health—and we share practical strategies for getting more of them. Everything from welcome email tweaks to pattern-interrupt campaigns.

And we even highlight our own examples—plus some examples from major newsletter experts like Mario Gabriele’s “Puzzler,” Toby Howell’s gamified email, and Katelyn Bourgoin’s Fri-Yay edition (part of her Why We Buy newsletter).

KEY TAKEAWAYS

Why replies are the ultimate engagement metric (and why open/click rates can mislead you)
How replies directly impact email deliverability
The underrated mental health boost creators get from reader replies
Why your welcome email is the #1 place to prioritize a reply CTA
Simple frameworks to write reply-worthy content (like Shaan Puri’s 7 emotions)
How pattern interrupt emails can spark hundreds of responses overnight
The surprising downsides: why Chenell’s 200-reply email also had record unsubscribes
Real-world examples: Mario Gabriele’s “Puzzler,” Toby Howell’s “Button Game,” and Katelyn Bourgoin’s Fri-Yay interactive polls
How replies can reveal new content ideas, products, or even potential clients
Why even a short personal story in your newsletter can trigger authentic responses

LINKS MENTIONED

Shaan Puri's 7 Key Emotions (+ AI Prompt Elicitor)
Mario Gabriele ('The Puzzler') GIR Deep Dive
Toby Howell's 'The Game' newsletter
Katelyn Bourgoin on GIR Podcast
Katelyn's Why We Buy (+ Fri-Yay) newsletter
Get Chenell's brand-new offering for newsletter creators: The Growth Vault — newsletter templates, growth strategies, and real examples you can implement at your own pace.
Want your newsletter roasted?Submit it here.
Ask us a question or submit a podcast topic idea: growthinreverse.com/questions
Check out past Growth In Reverse Deep Dives: https://growthinreverse.com/archive/

FOLLOW ON SOCIAL

Chenell: Twitter | LinkedIn | Substack
Dylan: LinkedIn | Bluesky

OUR NEWSLETTERS

Subscribe & Leave a Review:

If you found this episode valuable, take a second to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify! It helps more newsletter creators find the show. Plus, if you submit a review, you’ll get priority for your own newsletter roast!