Hyperfixed

How America Got Online

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • Jan Brandt solved AOL’s marketing problem by letting people try the internet through free physical disks instead of asking them to understand an unfamiliar service abstractly.
  • AOL’s direct-mail tests produced 12 percent response rates overall and 18 percent on one list, making the expensive CD campaign highly profitable despite an acquisition cost of about $35 per subscriber.
  • Brandt scaled distribution through computer magazines, Blockbuster boxes, airline snack service, and other unconventional placements, eventually making AOL CDs nearly impossible to avoid.
  • AOL’s success temporarily overloaded its own dial-up network, forcing the company to pause most marketing even though Brandt continued to defend the campaign’s growth economics.
  • Broadband removed AOL’s central function as the doorway to the internet, while open websites weakened the appeal of AOL’s curated walled garden.
  • The AOL-Time Warner merger failed because the companies had no workable integration vision, clashed culturally, and were hit by the dot-com crash and AOL’s accounting problems.
  • AOL correctly recognized that people went online primarily to find one another, but incorrectly assumed they would prefer professionally curated content inside a controlled environment.

Summary

The CD that made AOL synonymous with the internet

The host introduces the episode as a collaboration with Roman Mars’s 99% Invisible and BBC Studios’ A History of the U.S. in 100 Objects. In 1998, while the recording industry sold huge numbers of CDs—including nine million copies of the Titanic soundtrack—America Online was pressing more compact discs than any record label. AOL’s discs contained software, not music: inserting one connected a computer to the internet. Jan Brandt, AOL’s former chief marketing officer, says the discs became so ubiquitous that half of all CDs produced on Earth were AOL discs, turning AOL into the public’s shorthand for being online.

Why AOL needed a physical invitation

Brandt joined AOL in 1993 with only limited internet experience. She contrasted the company’s inviting, graphical service with the difficult pre-Web internet: the host recalls paying about $100 for a modem, dialing a local server with four phone lines, waiting through busy signals, and seeing only green text on black. AOL competed with business-oriented CompuServe and safety-focused Prodigy, which had ten times AOL’s users in 1993. Brandt says AOL’s “three C’s”—communications, community, and clarity—made it a place to meet friends, family, and fellow hobbyists through curated news, forums, games, email, and chat rooms.

Brandt’s $250,000 experiment

AOL cost $9.95 for five hours, then $3.50 per additional hour, and Brandt struggled to explain why people needed it when they already had phones, encyclopedias, and newspapers. Her solution was a free sample: send software on a floppy disk so people could experience the service rather than imagine it. She asked CEO Steve Case for $250,000, a major request for a company worth $38 million. Case approved it while teasing that he did not think it would work. Brandt targeted computer-magazine subscribers, mailing shrink-wrapped disks labeled, “It’s easy! It’s fun! It’s free!”

The response rate justified the mailing cost

Brandt tracked every mailing by list, group, and code so she could calculate each subscriber’s acquisition cost and projected lifetime value. Typical direct-mail response rates were one to 2.5 percent, but the AOL test produced 12 percent; one list produced an 18 percent response. Recipients installed the software and entered a credit-card number at roughly five times the rate of an average direct-mail campaign. Steve Case later said each new customer cost about $35 to acquire through an AOL CD, but generated ten times that amount in monthly fees. Brandt therefore argued that AOL should measure return, not the disks’ apparent expense.

From computer magazines to Blockbuster and airplanes

Brandt expanded distribution outward in “concentric circles,” moving from people who would have invented the internet themselves to curious mainstream users and eventually households without computers. AOL reached one million members by the summer after Brandt joined, requiring a machine that automatically inserted disks into mailers. She then attached disks to magazines, targeted families through Blockbuster rental gift boxes, and arranged for disks to accompany coffee and cookies on commuter business flights. AOL’s distribution became so extensive that Brandt calls it the largest mailer in the United States; the host recalls his father keeping a drawer full of AOL CDs.

Success overloaded AOL’s own network

The disks were useful to prospective customers but became an irritation to existing users, prompting the 2002 site nomoreaolcds.com to collect one million discs and mail them back. Brandt says senior managers repeatedly asked whether she could reduce the campaign, and she answered by asking how much subscriber growth they were willing to sacrifice. The strategy occasionally worked too well: waves of new users generated hours of busy signals, leading critics to call AOL “America on Hold.” AOL halted most marketing temporarily to relieve the overload, then resumed the campaign. By 2000, AOL had 25 million subscribers and claimed roughly half of internet users.

The merger that was supposed to define the future

In 2000, AOL and Time Warner announced a $160 billion merger, creating a company valued at about $350 billion. The deal joined America’s largest internet company with a media empire containing HBO, CNN, DC Comics, and other properties; it was promoted as the beginning of a new media era. Brandt corrects the host when he says AOL was bought by Time Warner: “We bought Time Warner,” though the companies called it a merger of equals. Almost immediately, however, the companies lacked a shared plan for combining AOL’s online service with Time Warner’s premium content.

Broadband made AOL’s doorway unnecessary

The merger’s problems began as broadband changed the internet AOL had built its business around. Dial-up users once needed AOL as the service they called before reaching the wider internet, but cable-based broadband offered always-on connections at vastly higher speeds. AOL tried to become a broadband provider through cable-company deals, yet the cable companies distrusted the company that had spent years operating around them and demanded too large a share of the revenue. Free web-hosting services also let users create their own pages, while the broader internet became more open and chaotic. People no longer needed AOL’s doorway—or wanted to remain inside its walls.

The dot-com crash and cultural mismatch deepened the losses

AOL’s advertising revenue depended heavily on internet companies whose valuations had been inflated by the dot-com bubble. When the bubble burst, AOL’s stock collapsed, damaging employees’ options, retirement savings, and morale; Brandt says everyone from assistants to janitorial staff held stock. Time Warner and AOL also clashed culturally: Time Warner was a New York suit-and-tie organization, while AOL arrived in jeans and sneakers. The companies had different personalities and no integration vision, and AOL was later found to have inflated advertising-revenue figures. In 2003 it reported a nearly $99 billion loss, then the largest corporate loss in history.

What AOL understood—and what it missed

AOL ended the disk campaign in 2006, spun off from Time Warner in 2009, bought sites including Huffington Post and TechCrunch, joined Verizon and Yahoo, and was eventually sold to an Italian technology conglomerate for $1.5 billion. The host argues that AOL understood the internet’s social half: the disk was a physical invitation, and users stayed to email relatives, join chat rooms, and connect with strangers. Reddit, Discord, and other services retain that social architecture. AOL misunderstood the content half by assuming people wanted a professionally curated walled garden; the internet proved more compelling when users could build the stages and fill them themselves.

Sponsors

  • Jack Archer · Jack Archer sells versatile men’s clothing designed for everyday use, including Jet Setter Tech Pants, shorts, and hoodies. The host says the pants are comfortable and jokes that he still does not know why they are called “Tech Pants.” The offer is 15% off a first order.
  • Uncommon Goods · Uncommon Goods offers thousands of unusual gifts in one place. The host recommends shopping before the holiday rush and mentions buying his daughter a Bluetooth black-and-white photo printer. The offer is 15% off a next gift.
  • Stio · Stio makes outdoor clothing designed and tested in Jackson Hole, Wyoming. The host describes wearing a Stio coat for winter hiking and mentions the 800-fill Hometown Down Jacket and award-winning Fernos jacket. The offer is 20% off an order.
  • Talkiatry · Talkiatry provides online psychiatric care through licensed clinicians who can diagnose conditions and prescribe medication when appropriate. The ad says its 800-plus clinicians are in-network with major insurers and can match patients with a psychiatrist in minutes.

Show notes

This week, a story made in partnership with 99% Invisible and The BBC as part of their project A History of the United States in 100 Objects. 

When Jan Brandt joined the marketing team of fledgling internet company America Online in 1993, she had to figure out how to sell a service that most people in the US had no idea how to use -- the internet. We talk to her about how she managed to use a small, unbiquitous physical object to help steer their virtual service toward the biggest corporate merger in history. 

Hyperfixed only exists because of your support. Please consider becoming a premium member. In addition to helping us stay afloat, you'll get bonus episodes, access to our discord, discounts on merch and live shows, and much more.

LINKS:
99% invisible

A History of the United States in 100 objects


Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file