Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing

Is a Japan-Style Downturn Possible in the U.S.?

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • Brokamp believes a Japan-style U.S. downturn is possible but unlikely under current conditions because Japan’s 1980s bubble combined extraordinary stock valuations, real-estate prices, and debt levels.
  • The U.S. market is historically expensive by the CAPE measure, so investors should be prepared for a possible decade or more of weak or volatile returns even without a Japan-scale collapse.
  • Money needed within three to five years should be kept in cash and bonds, while long-term investors can benefit from continuing to buy shares during a downturn.
  • For a retiree starting in 2000, a diversified six-asset portfolio had a higher bottom value, recovered above its initial balance sooner, and ultimately held $300,000 more than a simple stock-and-bond portfolio.

Summary

Japan’s three-part financial bubble

Robert Brokamp recalls how Japan appeared poised to overtake the U.S. in the 1980s, as Japanese companies bought Rockefeller Center, the Exxon Building, Pebble Beach Golf Club, Firestone, and Columbia Pictures. Japan’s stock, real-estate, and debt bubbles were all extreme: large-cap stocks returned over 22% annually from 1970–1989, small caps nearly 30%, and the market reached a 99 P/E ratio in December 1989. Japanese real estate became four times the value of U.S. real estate, while consumer debt grew sevenfold from 1979–1990. Rate increases beginning in May 1989 helped burst the bubble.

Why Brokamp does not expect a Japan-style U.S. collapse now

The Nikkei plunged in 1990, bottomed in 2009, and did not regain its prior peak until 2024. Brokamp says a similarly prolonged U.S. downturn is possible—the Dow fell almost 90% after 1929 and did not recover until 1954—but he does not think current U.S. conditions resemble Japan’s unusually frothy combination of stocks, property, and leverage. He cautions, however, that U.S. stocks are not cheap: the cyclically adjusted P/E, or CAPE, is at its second-highest level ever, surpassed only during the dot-com bubble, despite legitimate criticisms of its predictive power.

What the dot-com and financial crises say about expensive stocks

Brokamp uses the last period when U.S. valuations were similarly elevated as a warning to prepare for years of poor returns. The dot-com crash began in March 2000; the S&P 500 fell for three consecutive calendar years, losing 50%, then lost another 50% during the financial crisis that began in 2007. It took roughly 12 years for the S&P 500 to permanently regain its March 2000 peak and 16 years for the Nasdaq. For investors with goals more than a decade away, falling prices can help because ongoing IRA, 401(k), and brokerage contributions buy more shares.

Four defenses against a prolonged downturn

For near-term goals and people approaching or in retirement, Brokamp recommends protecting money needed within three to five years with cash and bonds; since 1928, U.S. large-cap stocks were profitable in 88% of five-year periods. He also recommends owning at least 50 stocks, noting that Walmart, McDonald’s, and AutoZone rose in 2008 while the S&P 500 fell 37%, and Exxon, Merck, and H&R Block rose in 2022 while the index fell 18%. He adds low-cost ETFs and index funds, with diversification across sectors, industries, styles, and countries.

Why the first retirement years matter most

Brokamp says diversification is particularly important during the first five to ten years of retirement. Retirement researcher Wade Pfau’s analysis found that early annual returns explain much of both accumulated wealth and sustainable withdrawals, while William Bengen, originator of the 4% rule, told Brokamp that successful withdrawal plans depend primarily on events in the first 10–12 retirement years. Brokamp therefore tests a retiree who began with $1 million in January 2000, withdrew $40,000 in the first year, and increased that withdrawal annually for inflation.

Diversification improved the 2000 retiree’s outcome

A 60% S&P 500/40% total-bond portfolio fell to $588,000 by February 2009, though it reached $1.2 million by September of the episode’s current year; it did not permanently exceed its original $1 million until May 2024. A six-asset portfolio—30% U.S. large caps, 14% U.S. small caps, 11% international stocks, 5% REITs, 35% bonds, and 5% cash—bottomed at $710,000, stayed above $1 million from June 2012, and reached $1.5 million. Brokamp concludes that diversification materially helped during this extended downturn.

Sponsors

  • Claude · Claude is presented as an AI collaborator for problem-solving, including debugging code, building financial models, strategizing business moves, researching sources, and continuing conversations across desktop and mobile through the cloud. The host recommends trying it on any paid plan and mentions Claude Pro, which includes the features discussed.

Show notes

The Japanese stock market crashed in 1990 and didn’t exceed its previous peak until 2024. Host Robert Brokamp answers a Fool’s question about whether such a long-term bear market could happen in the U.S.

Topics discussed:-The history of Japan’s financial asset bubble, which put most other bubbles to shame-The valuation of the U.S. stock market, and what happened the last time stocks were this pricey-Strategies for surviving a longer-term downturn-How the portfolio of someone who retired in 2000 has fared after retiring at the beginning of the worst stretch for U.S. stocks of modern times

Host: Robert Brokamp, CFP®, EAEngineer: Bart Shannon
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file