Planet Money

How investing is getting riskier (Two Indicators)

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • High levels of margin debt are raising concerns about potential market instability, especially if leveraged investments unwind during downturns.
  • Historical data from various countries show that excessive leverage can significantly amplify market crashes, and regulators might consider updating borrowing rules to prevent similar crises.
  • A disturbing trend among Generation Z involves confusing sports betting with investing, driven by aggressive marketing and overconfidence, which can lead to financial hardship.
  • State-level policy changes, like in Colorado, are attempting to introduce safeguards against problem gambling, but the effectiveness of these measures remains to be seen.

Summary

The Rise of Margin Trading and Its Risks

This section discusses the unprecedented levels of margin borrowing in the US stock market, which now surpasses $1.5 trillion, reflecting more aggressive investment strategies. Experts warn that high margin debt can amplify market downturns, citing historical instances where excess leverage contributed to crashes. The discussion highlights how traders face difficult choices when stocks decline—either sell assets or deposit more money—potentially exacerbating losses, especially during crises like in India where margin trading caused significant amplification of market declines.

Global Examples of Leverage-Driven Market Volatility

This section looks at recent events in South Korea and India, where leveraged ETFs and margin trading respectively led to sharp declines. In Korea, the rapid increase in leveraged ETF investments, especially in semiconductor stocks, resulted in a 40% market plunge due to unwinding of leverage. Young investors, often under 35, bore the brunt of these losses. In India, regulatory differences allowed better research on how margin trading influences market stability, confirming that margin calls and forced selling intensify downturns during financial crises.

Potential Federal Interventions and Future Risks

The discussion shifts to the possible role of the Federal Reserve in regulating margin debt in the US. Historically, the Fed has set borrowing requirements but hasn't updated them since 1974. Experts suggest that adjusting these requirements, possibly making borrowing tougher, could slow the rise of risky leverage. However, given that the current increase in margin debt is slower than previous bubbles, some believe the US is only in a 'yellow zone' rather than imminent danger. The debate emphasizes the difficulty of timing market bubbles and the Fed's cautious approach.

The Blurring Lines Between Investment and Gambling Among Youths

This section explores the alarming trend where a significant portion of Gen Z perceives sports betting as an investment strategy and uses investment funds for gambling, often driven by attractive bonus offers and advertising. Younger people, feeling disconnected from the economy, see gambling as a quick path to wealth, despite the high risks involved. Experts warn that the overconfidence and lack of self-control among youth can lead to significant financial problems, especially when combined with aggressive marketing and unsecured betting practices.

Regulatory and Policy Responses to Problem Gambling

Focus shifts to state-level efforts, notably in Colorado, which introduced regulations such as banning credit card deposits and implementing deposit limits to mitigate problem gambling. These measures aim to reduce risky and compulsive behaviors, especially among young men, recognizing gambling addiction's serious social consequences like bankruptcies and suicides. The episodes highlight ongoing experimentation with policies to curb gambling's harms and debate whether these measures can be effective in protecting vulnerable populations.

Sponsors

  • Pure Insurance · Pure Insurance is motivated by its members. Nearly 170 million dollars have been allocated to members. Learn more at pureinsurance.com.

Show notes

Margin borrowing and sports gambling “investments” are both on the rise! Today on the show, two stories from Planet Money’s daily podcast The Indicator about the ways investing is changing, and getting riskier.

According to one study, more than half of Gen Zers are using investment dollars for sports gambling. On average, this is not a smart strategy for the long term. It might be that sports betting today is like day trading was for a previous generation of young investors: something a lot of young people, typically men, do, lose money at for a while, then quit. We review the early research on this trend and meet a state legislator proposing ways to stem problem gambling.

More, generally younger people are also investing with borrowed money. Trading on margin is at an all time high of over $1.5 trillion. In the past, high levels of margin investing have led to crashes. We hear those stories and find out what the Fed might do to reign in the risk. 

Related Indicator episodes
— How AI might mess with financial markets
— Prediction markets are threatening national security. Who's gonna fix it?

Connect with Planet Money & The Indicator
— Sign up for The Indicator’s weekly link round up newsletter!
— Sign up for Planet Money’s weekly longform newsletter!
— Buy the Planet Money book
— Find our socials, YouTube and more!
— For sponsor-free episodes, subscribe to NPR+ 

Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include bonus episodes and sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org.

These episodes of The Indicator from Planet Money were produced by Corey Bridges and Cooper Katz-McKim. They were engineered by Travis Hagan and Cena Loffredo, and fact-checked by Sierra Juarez. They were edited by Julia Ritchey and Kate Concannon. 

Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include bonus episodes and sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file