The hidden world behind your new "banking" app

Key takeaways

Fintech companies like Yada can resemble traditional banks but often skirt crucial regulations.
Consumers should be wary of banking apps that do not clearly identify themselves as non-banks.
The fallout from fintech failures can have severe consequences for customers, as evidenced by the Yada debacle.
There is a need for clearer regulations concerning fintech and the entities that support them to protect consumers.
Understanding the difference between actual banks and fintechs is crucial for consumer protection and financial security.

Summary

Introduction to Fintech Pitfalls

The episode begins by highlighting the contrast between traditional banks and the rise of fintech companies, which claim to offer convenient digital banking services without the traditional drawbacks. The episode focuses on a couple, Shadinda and Jordan, who discover the appeal of a fintech app called Yada that promises to gamify saving through lottery-style rewards.

The Allure of Yada and the Banking Illusion

Shadinda and Jordan, feeling constrained by their previous financial habits, find Yada's premise intriguing—saving money while potentially winning prizes. Despite the fun marketing that creates a sense of security (including FDIC insurance claims), the reality of the app’s banking structure starts their journey toward trouble.

The Yada Crisis

The situation escalates when Shadinda’s debit card is declined, despite them having saved approximately $6,000. After an investigation, it becomes clear that a middle company, Synapse, which was responsible for managing Yada’s customer deposits, had declared bankruptcy, resulting in the freezing of funds for thousands of customers.

Understanding Fintech Regulation

The discussion turns to the regulatory environment, explaining that fintech companies like Yada operate in a grey area, circumventing traditional banking regulations. Guests share insights about the complexities of these apps that market themselves like banks, while not actually adhering to the requirements of being one.

The Effect on Customers and Regulatory Implications

Listeners hear about the frustrations of those affected by the freezing of funds, including Shadinda and Jordan. Moreover, regulatory failures are brought to the forefront, questioning who is responsible for overseeing fintech companies and whether stricter rules are needed to prevent such crises in the future.

Show notes

You might have seen ads for online banking services that seem to offer a lot of great stuff — accounts you can open in minutes and without a minimum balance or monthly fees. The ads seem to say: "These aren't your parents' boring old banks." But the truth is: Even though they might resemble banks, they aren't.

These "bank-like" companies are a type of "fintech" or financial technology company. And this is a story about the potential risks of putting your money into these apps.

Banks go through a whole regulatory gauntlet in order to exist. But, in the past several years, there has been a rise in fintechs that skirt regulations. And many of these pose a real threat to even the most savvy of depositors.

When a little known tech company filed for bankruptcy a few months ago, thousands of people couldn't access the millions of dollars they saved. On today's show, we meet some of the people affected and learn what the fintech industry reveals about banking regulation.

Today's show was hosted by Erika Beras and Sally Helm. It was produced by Sam Yellowhorse Kesler and Sofia Shchukina with help from James Sneed. It was edited by Jess Jiang and fact-checked by Kevin Volkl. It was engineered by Valentina Rodríguez Sánchez with help from James Willetts. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.

Help support Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy