Radiolab
What Up Holmes?
· Summarized
Key takeaways
- Oliver Wendell Holmes played a crucial role in shaping the modern interpretation of free speech in America.
- Holmes's views evolved significantly during a critical eight-month period influenced by his relationships with a younger progressive intellectual circle.
- The marketplace of ideas metaphor idealizes how discourse functions in society, yet current data shows misinformation spreads faster than truth, challenging this ideal.
- There is a growing call to rethink free speech frameworks to prioritize the rights of listeners and quality of information over mere vocalization of opinions.
Summary
The Evolution of Free Speech in America
In this episode, hosts Latif Nasser and Simon Adler reflect on a previous discussion with law professor Kate Klonick about the evolution of free speech in the United States, particularly in the context of modern social media. The conversation highlights how free speech as we understand it today can be traced back to Oliver Wendell Holmes, a Supreme Court Justice who significantly shaped the First Amendment's interpretation. The hosts explore how debates on free speech date back to the First Amendment's inception and discuss Holmes's pivotal transformation in thought during a critical eight-month period.
Holmes’s Transformation: A Case Study on Free Speech
The episode delves into the pivotal cases of the Espionage Act during World War I and how Holmes initially upheld the convictions of individuals who spoke against the war effort. It examines Holmes's dissent in the Abrams case, where he dramatically shifted his stance on free speech, advocating for an open marketplace of ideas. The narrative explores the mystery behind this transformation, considering Holmes's relationships with young progressive intellectuals who influenced his views.
The Marketplace of Ideas: Idealism vs. Reality
The hosts engage in a critical analysis of the 'marketplace of ideas' metaphor and its implications for free speech. They discuss the idealistic view that truth will rise to the top in a free exchange of ideas but highlight the reality that misinformation often spreads more quickly than truth, especially in today’s digital landscape. The episode presents data from researchers that demonstrates how lies spread more rapidly and widely than factual information, complicating the concept of a functional marketplace of ideas.
Reimagining Free Speech: Perspectives and Solutions
In a discussion with media lawyer Nabiha Sayed, the hosts explore alternative frameworks for understanding free speech beyond the marketplace of ideas concept. Sayed emphasizes the importance of the listener's rights and suggests considering the facts necessary for informed democratic participation as a focus for free speech discussions. The conversation encourages a rethinking of regulatory practices around speech, recognizing the need for a new framework that better reflects the complexities of modern communication and societal needs.
Sponsors
- Progressive Insurance · Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Well, with the name your price tool from Progressive, you can find options that fit your budget and potentially lower your bills. Try it at Progressive.com, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates, Price and Coverage Match limited by state law, not available in all states.
- AT&T · There's nothing better than that feeling like someone has your back and that things are going to get done without you even having to ask like your friend offering to help you move without even having to offer drinks and pizza first. It's a beautiful thing when someone has two steps ahead of you quietly making your life easier. Staying connected matters. That's why in the rare event of a network outage AT&T will proactively credit you for a full day of service. Visit ATT.com/guarantee for full details.
Show notes
Love it or hate it, the freedom to say obnoxious and subversive things is the quintessence of what makes America America. But our say-almost-anything approach to free speech is actually relatively recent, and you can trace it back to one guy: a Supreme Court justice named Oliver Wendell Holmes. Even weirder, you can trace it back to one seemingly ordinary eight-month period in Holmes’s life when he seems to have done a logical U-turn on what should be say-able. Why he changed his mind during those eight months is one of the greatest mysteries in the history of the Supreme Court. (Spoiler: the answer involves anarchists, a house of truth, and a cry for help from a dear friend.) Join us in an episode we originally released in 2021, as we investigate why he changed his mind, how that made the country change its mind, and whether it’s now time to change our minds again.
Special thanks to Jenny Lawton, Soren Shade, Kelsey Padgett, Mahyad Tousi and Soroush Vosughi.
LATERAL CUTS:
Content Warning
Facebook Supreme Court
The Trust Engineers
EPISODE CREDITS:
Reported by - Latif Nasser
Produced by - Sarah Qari
with help from - Anisa Vietze
Signup for our newsletter!! It includes short essays, recommendations, and details about other ways to interact with the show. Sign up (https://radiolab.org/newsletter)!
Radiolab is supported by listeners like you. Support Radiolab by becoming a member of The Lab (https://members.radiolab.org/) today.
Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @radiolab, and share your thoughts with us by emailing radiolab@wnyc.org.
Leadership support for Radiolab’s science programming is provided by the Simons Foundation and the John Templeton Foundation. Foundational support for Radiolab was provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account