Raging Moderates: Why Progressives Won’t WIN in the 2026 Midterms (ft. David Frum)

Key takeaways

Democratic campaigns are focusing on running against Trump, which may energize the base but risks sounding outdated.
Graham Platner's past controversies illustrate the complexities of modern candidacies and the expectations around personal accountability.
The legality and morality of military actions in foreign nations provoke significant discussion, particularly regarding striking drug traffickers.
Progressive messaging needs to strike a balance between ideals and practical appeal for broader voter engagement.
The gerontocracy in politics raises concerns about the effectiveness of aging leaders and the importance of nurturing younger talent.

Summary

Democrats Running Against Trump

Jessica Tarlov and guest David Frum discuss the ongoing strategy of Democratic candidates who are choosing to run against Donald Trump, despite his unpopularity. They analyze whether this tactic is effective or if it starts to feel stale, particularly as the party grapples with a potential lack of forward-looking vision. The conversation highlights concerns about the long-term consequences of consistently framing the opposition as merely an extension of Trump, questioning if this approach is adequate for engaging a broader electorate.

Graham Platner's Controversy

The discussion pivots to Maine Senate candidate Graham Platner, whose campaign has faced setbacks after years’ worth of offensive online comments surfaced. Tarlov and Frum critique Platner's response to these revelations, considering whether his acknowledgment of past mistakes is enough to maintain support against the more traditional candidacy of Gov. Janet Mills. The impact of this controversy on modern campaigns, particularly among younger candidates, is examined in light of past and potential support within the party.

Trump's Caribbean Strikes

The hosts delve into Trump's recent military strikes in the Caribbean, raising questions about the motives behind these actions. Frum remarks on the complex relationship between the US and Colombia, referencing the historical context of drugs and economics in both regions. The conversation addresses the moral implications of military actions that harm innocent civilians and the varying perspectives within US politics regarding military intervention in foreign nations.

Challenges of Progressive Messaging

Tarlov and Frum explore the difficulties of effectively communicating a progressive platform today, particularly in midterm elections. They consider whether candidates need to adopt more centrist messages to appeal to a broader audience or if sticking with progressive ideals could ultimately yield favorable outcomes. The conversation touches upon the need for adaptable strategies and the challenges posed by disparate party narratives.

Aging Politicians and Future Leadership

The podcast concludes with a discussion of gerontocracy within politics, stressing the importance of youth leadership and the challenges faced by aging politicians, including Joe Biden and Janet Mills. Frum posits that there may be a crucial balance between experience and vitality, questioning how voters can identify and select leaders who are both capable and ready to navigate contemporary issues.

Show notes

On the heels of the No Kings protests that drew an estimated seven million Americans, there seems to be a strong coalition to take on Trump and the GOP. But, what will the Democrats’ message be? Jessica Tarlov and guest host David Frum of The Atlantic discuss the Democratic Party’s predicament — and the value of tacking to the center. Plus: is there a justifiable rationale for the Trump administration’s deadly strikes on boats in the Caribbean? And, Maine Senate candidate Graham Platner’s insurgent campaign was set back last week by years of past internet comments coming to light. He has taken responsibility for his remarks — but, in a primary against Gov. Janet Mills, will it matter?