Stuff You Should Know

Selects: The Taliesin Massacre

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • Taliesin was Wright’s deeply personal Wisconsin home, studio, school, and architectural autobiography, not merely another commission.
  • Wright abandoned his wife, six children, and financial obligations to pursue Mamah Borthwick, publicly framing the decision as a necessary “voluntary exile.”
  • Carlton’s behavior had become increasingly alarming before the massacre, but authorities never established a definitive motive for the attack.
  • On August 15, 1914, Carlton used gasoline and an axe to kill Mamah, her two children, and four employees at Taliesin, while three victims initially escaped and two later died from injuries.
  • Carlton survived his attempted suicide by fire and hydrochloric acid but died in jail seven weeks later from starvation or self-imposed starvation.
  • The hosts argue that Wright’s extraordinary architectural achievements and his selfish, destructive personal conduct must be considered separately, though whether to do so remains a personal judgment.

Summary

Why Taliesin mattered to Frank Lloyd Wright

Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant introduce Taliesin as Frank Lloyd Wright’s home, studio, school, and 800-acre Wisconsin estate, built on the hill his Welsh maternal ancestors had homesteaded near Spring Green. Completed around 1911, the roughly 21,000-square-foot property expressed Wright’s prairie style through horizontal lines, natural materials, woodworking, and a design intended to blend with its surroundings. It reportedly had 524 windows and no gutters because Wright wanted to see winter icicles hanging from the roof. The hosts discuss visiting other Wright buildings, including Fallingwater, Taliesin West, Hollyhock House, the Guggenheim, and a Wright-designed Florida Southern campus.

Wright’s affair with Mamah Borthwick

Wright met Mamah Borthwick in 1903 while designing a house for her and her husband, Edwin Cheney. Their professional relationship became an affair by about 1907; Wright was already famous, had six children, and had designed about 50 prairie houses in Chicago’s Oak Park between 1900 and 1910. The hosts say he had grown bored with the architectural style everyone wanted and may have sought emotional escape as well as professional freedom. By 1908 the affair was an open secret, and Wright’s wife, Kitty, endured public humiliation while still insisting that Wright was sincere and would return.

The “spiritual Hegira” to Europe

In September 1909, Wright left Kitty and their six children to travel to Europe with Mamah, who left her two children with Cheney. Wright described the abandonment in his autobiography as a “voluntary exile” undertaken because family life supposedly threatened the freedom to which every soul was entitled. He called the trip a “spiritual Hegira,” comparing their escape to Muhammad’s departure from Mecca. Newspapers exposed the couple, who could not travel anonymously because Wright was internationally recognizable. The hosts also note Wright’s lifelong financial irresponsibility: despite lucrative commissions, he spent heavily and reportedly left a $900 grocery bill behind when he abandoned his family.

Returning to Chicago and building Taliesin

Wright returned to Chicago in 1910 while Mamah stayed in Europe to complete her divorce. Kitty described his return as bringing “everything but his heart,” which she believed he had left in Germany. Wright and Mamah were socially rejected by neighbors, colleagues, and Chicago high society; one neighbor’s mother even refused Wright cream, calling the couple sinners. Wright then asked benefactor Darwin Martin for $25,000 to build a Wisconsin home, claiming it would be for his mother rather than a residence for him and Mamah. He received the money, moved into Taliesin with Mamah by Christmas 1911, and never repaid Martin’s total career loans of $75,000, even after Martin lost everything in the 1929 crash.

The lunch before the attack

On Saturday, August 15, 1914, Mamah sat on Taliesin’s terrace with her children, ten-year-old John and eight-year-old Martha, while five Wright employees and the foreman’s son ate inside: Emil Burdell, Thomas Brunker, David Lindblom, Herbert Fritz, William Weston, and Ernst Weston. The property’s handyman, Julian Carlton, served both groups. In the preceding weeks and months, Carlton had become aggressive and strange, argued with others, talked about killing people, and slept beside a hatchet and a sack. Rumors said he and his wife, Gertrude, were being dismissed and planned to take a train to Chicago for new work.

Carlton’s gasoline-and-axe attack

After serving lunch, Carlton asked Weston for permission to take gasoline from a shed, supposedly to clean rugs. He returned with the gasoline and an axe, killed Mamah and her two children outside, then poured gasoline beneath the dining-room doors and set the room and house on fire with the employees trapped inside. As people escaped through a window, Carlton followed them and attacked them with the axe, sometimes striking victims who were already on fire. Seven of the nine people dining at Taliesin died. Draftsman Herbert Fritz escaped first, and badly burned employee David Lindblom ran roughly half a mile with him to get help, later dying from his burns.

Carlton’s failed suicide and unknown motive

Authorities eventually found Carlton in an asbestos-lined basement boiler room. The hosts disagree over whether he entered the furnace area to die in the fire or to shelter from it, but both agree that he drank hydrochloric acid after being discovered or after deciding the fire would not kill him. He survived the fire and the acid, though the acid destroyed his throat and stomach. He died in jail seven weeks later, either because he could not eat or because he deliberately starved himself. No conclusive motive was established; the hosts infer severe mental illness but also point to his perceived treatment, possible dismissal, and the couple’s impending departure.

Wright hears that Taliesin is burning

Wright was in Chicago working on Midway Gardens with his son John Lloyd Wright when the news arrived. John later recalled an unnatural silence broken by Wright’s labored breathing, followed by the instruction, “John, a taxi. Taliesin is on fire.” Wright learned the murders from reporters shouting questions as he traveled to the train station, rather than from authorities or family. The Chicago newspaper headline, “The End of Lawless Loves,” treated the killings as a sensational consequence of Wright’s affair. The hosts stress that Wright initially did not know people had been murdered when he heard about the fire.

Wright’s later relationships, work, and the book

The massacre deeply affected Wright’s work and relationship with the press for roughly two decades, but his romantic life remained turbulent. He entered a destructive relationship with artist and morphine addict Miriam Noel, married her in 1923 after divorcing Kitty, and separated from her about six months later; she later caused trouble with the press and had him briefly arrested under the Mann Act. In 1924 he married Olga Lazovich Hinzenburg, with whom he had a daughter in 1925, and they remained together until his death in 1959. His later productive period included Taliesin West, Fallingwater, and the Guggenheim. The episode closes with the hosts promoting their book, “Stuff You Should Know: An Incomplete Compendium of Mostly Interesting Things.”

Sponsors

  • Capital One · The ad promotes checking accounts with no fees or minimums and Capital One Cafés, which are open seven days a week. It directs listeners to learn more about the Capital One Bank Guy.
  • Costco on Uber Eats · Costco members can order groceries, household essentials, and other Costco products through Uber Eats. The ad offers 20% off the first three orders with code UberCostco, up to $60 total savings, for orders of $100 or more.
  • Eating Interrupted · This iHeartRuby Studio podcast, hosted by journalist and Crohn’s patient Cynthia McFadden, examines what happens when the body does not respond to food as expected and explores the science of digestion and related conditions.
  • Bombas · Bombas sells socks, slippers, footwear, underwear, and T-shirts, and donates one essential clothing item for every item purchased. The ad says Bombas has made more than 200 million donations and offers 20% off the first purchase with code SYSK.
  • Voices of Vivgart · This podcast features people living with rare diseases and discusses diagnosis, treatment plans, setbacks, progress, and life after diagnosis, hosted by Andra Stratton.
  • Wayfair · Wayfair promotes home products for holiday hosting, including appliances and larger renovations. Its products are reviewed through a 10-point quality inspection, and the ad cites more than 20 million verified five-star reviews.
  • Lowe’s · Lowe’s advertises Black Friday deals, including up to three free select power tools with qualifying DeWalt, Craftsman, or Cobalt battery-kit purchases, plus select $99 holiday artificial Christmas trees.
  • Quince · Quince sells premium-material staples such as Mongolian cashmere, 14-karat gold, and Italian leather at prices the ad says are 50% to 80% below similar brands. It offers free shipping and 365-day returns.
  • GSK Extensure · Extensure is presented as an ultra-long-acting prescription add-on treatment for severe eosinophilic asthma in people 12 and older. The ad says it can help protect against asthma attacks with two doses per year and warns about serious allergic reactions.
  • Bank of America · Bank of America promotes Advantage SafeBalance Banking, emphasizing no overdraft item fees and no monthly maintenance fee for customers under 25.
  • Coca-Cola · Coca-Cola is advertised as a drink for people of every personality and circumstance, from introverts and extroverts to risk takers, optimists, old friends, and new.

Show notes

Everyone knows who Frank Lloyd Wright is, but did you know there was a grisly massacre at his home in 1914? Find out all about it in this classic episode.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file