Stuff You Should Know

The Wilmington Massacre

· Summarized

Share this episode
Anyone with this link can open it.
Share Link
Start at 0:00

Key takeaways

  • The 1898 Wilmington violence was an organized white supremacist coup that removed a democratically elected local government, not a spontaneous race riot.
  • The Fusionist alliance between Populists and Republicans briefly increased Black and working-class political power through shared candidates and policies.
  • White supremacist leaders used newspapers, racist propaganda, armed patrols, voter intimidation, ballot manipulation, and violence together rather than relying on one tactic.
  • Wilmington’s Black residents had significant businesses, banks, elected officials, and civic influence, although Jim Crow restrictions still limited their rights.
  • The massacre killed an uncertain number of Black residents, forced many others from Wilmington, and was followed by the takeover of city government and systematic voter suppression.
  • Black voter registration in North Carolina fell from 125,000 in 1896 to 6,000 in 1902, while segregation and disenfranchisement expanded.
  • The event was covered up for decades, with the official “race riot” framing not replaced by the term “massacre” until a state commission’s work around 2000.

Summary

A coup against Wilmington’s Black political power

Josh and Chuck introduce the Wilmington Massacre as an organized 1898 coup by white supremacists against Black residents who had gained political power through voting and elected office. They call it likely the only successful coup in American history and compare it with the Tulsa massacre, emphasizing that Wilmington’s violence was part of a broader pattern in which dominant groups attacked minorities. The hosts stress that the story was buried for decades and that the mob did not merely kill people: it overturned a democratically elected local government and helped suppress Black political participation across North Carolina.

The Fusionist coalition wins elections in North Carolina

After the 15th Amendment and Reconstruction, Southern Democrats used law and violence to suppress Black political power, but in the 1890s the Populist Party joined with the Republicans in the Fusionist Movement. The coalition avoided running against itself, adopted shared policies, and appealed to farmers and laborers with proposals such as limiting interest rates, making homeownership more affordable, increasing education funding, and making ballots accessible to illiterate voters through party colors and designs. In the 1896 election, Fusionists elected Republican Daniel L. Russell governor and Black officials including George H. White, who became the only Black U.S. congressman from 1897 to 1901.

Wilmington becomes a Black-majority center of influence

Wilmington, North Carolina, had about 20,000 residents and was the state’s largest municipality. It was majority Black, with Black doctors, attorneys, business owners, three Black-owned banks, and elected Black officials serving as treasurer, jailer, coroner, and police officers; 10 of the city’s 26 police officers were Black. The hosts caution that this was not a multiracial utopia: Black officers could not arrest white people, and Jim Crow remained in force. Still, compared with the surrounding South, Wilmington represented substantial political and economic progress, which threatened wealthy white elites who were losing control.

The White Supremacy Campaign turns class conflict into racial fear

Democratic leader Furnifold M. Simmons organized the explicitly named “White Supremacy Campaign” to draw white working-class voters away from the Fusionists. The campaign portrayed Black political influence as “Negro domination,” while the Raleigh News and Observer, edited by Josephus Daniels, published exaggerated or fabricated accounts depicting Black people as criminals and sexual threats. Black newspaper editor Alex Manly of Wilmington’s Daily Record challenged those claims by arguing that white men routinely raped Black women and that some relationships between Black men and white women were consensual or loving. White advertisers abandoned his paper, his landlord evicted it, and he received death threats.

Red Shirts use organized intimidation before the election

The campaign paired propaganda with a terrorist organization called the Red Shirts, which spread from South Carolina into North Carolina. Wilmington Democrats organized nightly patrols with a captain for each ward and a lieutenant for each block, arming men with Gatling guns and Hotchkiss guns while portraying Black residents as the supposed threat. The News and Observer even treated Black men’s attempts to buy rifles and pistols as suspicious news. Before the election, Red Shirts fired into Black homes and a school, stabbed at least two Black men, and held a torchlit parade of armed white men. Alfred Moore Waddell repeatedly threatened to fill the Cape Fear River with Black bodies.

The 1898 election is stolen through force and fraud

On Election Day, Red Shirts and other white supremacists blocked Black voters from reaching the polls or intimidated them into staying home. In Black-majority precincts, white registrars could replace Republican ballots with Democratic ones; at one precinct, the Democratic candidate received about 150 votes more than the number of registered voters. Fusionists had won Wilmington by 5,000 votes in 1896 but lost by 6,000 in 1898. Governor Daniel Russell, a white Republican from Wilmington, returned to vote publicly, but Red Shirts hijacked his train afterward and tried to lynch him, forcing him to hide in the mail car.

Waddell demands that Wilmington’s Black leaders surrender

Because Wilmington’s municipal offices were not up for election until the following year, white supremacists continued their effort to remove the city’s elected leadership. On November 9, a notice headed “Attention White Men” summoned supporters to the courthouse, where Waddell read a document later called the Wilmington Declaration of Independence. It demanded an end to “rule by Negroes” and the removal of the Daily Record, the mayor, and the police chief; about 450 people signed it. Waddell then summoned 32 Black civic leaders, demanded that they resign and accept permanent white control, and gave them until 7:30 the next morning to comply. They sent a conciliatory response by post, but armed guards kept them from delivering it directly.

The mob burns the Daily Record and attacks Brooklyn

On November 10, roughly 500 armed white men gathered at the Wilmington Light Infantry Armory. Led by Waddell and joined by others along the way, the group grew to about 2,000 and marched on the Daily Record. Manly had escaped, so the mob burned the newspaper office instead. It then moved into the Black neighborhood of Brooklyn, firing indiscriminately into Black homes and businesses on the way to a cotton-processing facility that employed many Black workers. When the governor ordered the local military commander to restore peace, the Light Infantry and naval reservists joined the attackers or stood by while the violence continued.

The massacre installs a new government and erases the truth

The attackers used Hotchkiss and Gatling guns, hanged and shot residents, ransacked Black churches, and killed people simply for being Black in the wrong place. Armed men surrounded Black politician Daniel Wright’s home, ordered him to run, and shot him in the back. Estimates range from 14 in a false coroner’s report to as many as 300; a 2006 state report said up to 60. Waddell forced the mayor, police chief, and other officials to resign, declared himself mayor, and installed white conspirators. Black residents hid in swamps, woods, and a cemetery; about 10% eventually left. No one was prosecuted. Black voter registration fell from 125,000 in 1896 to 6,000 in 1902, and segregation followed.

A decades-long cover-up finally calls it a massacre

White newspapers denied that a mob existed and described the violence as a “unanimous uprising of the white people.” Waddell called it the “good old Anglo-Saxon way” of overthrowing intolerable government and claimed that deposed Black officials recognized their own “utter helpless imbecility.” The event was commonly labeled a race riot until a North Carolina commission formally called it a massacre around 2000. The hosts cite Helen Gray Edmonds’s 1951 account and a 2010 PBS documentary as later efforts to correct the record. They close with listener mail from Steph and Jude, who have listened together since her son was in the womb and now use the show as a family tradition.

Sponsors

  • Grainger · Grainger says its $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps procurement managers at industrial manufacturing facilities get critical supplies when needed, balancing budgets and keeping production moving.
  • Chase for Business · Chase promotes local support and business resources for more than 7 million customers, including Chase Business Complete Checking. New business checking customers can earn $500 with qualifying activities; the offer expires January 21, 2027, and fees and eligibility requirements apply.
  • Cosentyx · Cosentyx is advertised for adults and children 12 and older with moderate to severe hidradenitis suppurativa. The ad says to discuss treatment with a dermatologist familiar with HS and warns about infections, tuberculosis, inflammatory bowel disease symptoms, allergic reactions, and severe eczema-like skin reactions.

Show notes

In the late 1800s, white supremacists in Wilmington, NC staged a coup and bloody massacre of its black citizens in order to stem the tide of black progress and stifle the vote. This is that story.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account

Couldn't load the audio. A blocker may be stopping the show's tracking links. Open the file