Confidence - How Important Is It? - Josh Cox, Dave Maddock and Derin McMains, ReliaQuest Performance Coaches
· Summarized
Key takeaways
- Confidence should be treated as trust supported by evidence, while belief can exist before proof; faith and courage help people act before confidence is fully earned.
- Developing competency through preparation, repetition, and team rehearsal is more reliable than waiting to feel completely confident.
- Skill confidence, team confidence, and authentic confidence are distinct; the strongest performers develop all three.
- Authentic confidence means not treating success, failure, roles, or results as a complete definition of personal worth.
- Purpose provides a larger source of value when an immediate performance or career outcome goes badly.
- Comparison can reveal gaps and improve self-awareness, but attention should remain focused on one’s own performance.
- Leaders should identify the one sentence that captures their identity and their organization’s identity, then use it to guide behavior and decisions.
Summary
Confidence cannot be developed until it is defined
Host Derin McMains opens by asking Josh Cox and Dave Maddock whether confidence is necessary for success. Cox says the term must be defined alongside belief and competency. He describes competency as having the skills, knowledge, habits, and behaviors to perform a task correctly every time, progressing from unconscious incompetence to conscious incompetence, conscious competence, and finally unconscious competence. Maddock notes that people can appear confident both when they are highly competent and when they are unaware of their incompetence—the latter being “karaoke bar” or misplaced confidence.
Belief is not the same as earned confidence
Maddock distinguishes belief from confidence: belief is thinking something is possible with or without evidence, while confidence is trust based on evidence that has been earned. Someone may believe they can start a business without being confident because they have never done it. Cox adds that belief is often the first step toward confidence, especially when someone has to act before evidence exists. The group also introduces faith as “assurance in the things unseen,” arguing that faith can get people through the first attempt and create the evidence on which later confidence depends.
Performance requires action before certainty
The speakers define performance as executing a task to a standard despite resistance, including internal doubt. Maddock says a lack of preparation or belief can show up in public speaking and other high-pressure situations. Cox argues that confidence is overrated if it becomes a prerequisite: as a former Navy SEAL, he could never wait until he was 100 percent certain that every mission would work perfectly, because every operation was different. Instead, he focused on building individual and team competency through preparation and rehearsal, creating the best possible conditions for confident performance without any guarantee of success.
The three forms of confidence
Maddock organizes confidence into three categories. Skill confidence comes from training and competence; team confidence comes from seeing capable teammates to the left and right and trusting that they have rehearsed together; authentic confidence comes from knowing that one’s worth does not depend on success or failure. Someone with authentic confidence can give a presentation, make a mistake, or fail and still know they are okay. Cox warns that people who possess only skill confidence may tie their value to uncontrollable results. The group says adaptability and resilience matter more than confidence in one narrow skill.
Purpose gives confidence somewhere to return to
When McMains asks how authentic confidence is developed, Maddock says people need to be connected to something larger than results. He compares purpose to giving a child a bigger lollipop: a stronger purpose makes it easier to release the smaller, immediate reward. He applies this to sales, arguing that salespeople should see themselves as helping customers solve problems rather than being trapped by sales metrics. If one performance goes badly, a person who also values being a parent, teammate, or community member can still find meaning and value elsewhere.
A SEAL team’s “perfect” result can still contain mistakes
Cox explains that after hundreds of SEAL missions, he cannot recall one that was perfect, even when the result was successful. Debriefs after apparently good missions could be especially difficult because the team still had to identify mistakes and improve. The speakers separate performance from results: imperfect performance can produce a perfect result, while excellent preparation cannot control every outcome. Cox says his own authentic confidence was tied strongly to his team and to the desire not to let teammates down, which supplied purpose even when he personally felt unready.
Comparison can expose reality without controlling attention
The group considers how confidence changes when someone compares themselves with a more accomplished teammate. Cox cites the SEAL saying “two frogmen equals a race”: teammates compete to outperform one another but do not sabotage one another. Comparison can provide a useful reality check, but attention should remain on one’s own performance rather than another person’s speed. Maddock recalls arriving at professional baseball’s extended spring training as an All-American believing he was great, only to discover that even players at the lowest professional level were highly capable. The experience showed him he had a long way to go.
The one-sentence test for authentic confidence
Maddock offers a practical exercise: decide what one sentence people should say about you at the end of your life. A mentor told him that people ultimately remember someone in a single phrase, such as George Washington being “the first president.” Maddock wants his sentence to be that people felt loved, served, and better when he was around, regardless of whether he reached his baseball goal. Cox tells a SEAL story in which a senior master chief resolved a scheduling dispute by writing “be a good dude” on a Post-it note, turning a complex standard into a simple identity.
How leaders should build confidence on their teams
The hosts conclude that lacking confidence is feedback about missing evidence, skill reps, or clarity about identity—not a reason to stop performing. Cox says leaders should develop skill confidence in themselves and their teams, establish team confidence by ensuring the right people rehearse together, and model authentic confidence by knowing their own guiding sentence. Organizations should also define their own sentence through mission, vision, and values, then revisit it regularly. He adds that “a leader without any followers is just someone taking a walk alone,” so confidence-building must serve the team rather than the leader’s ego.
Sponsors
- ReliaQuest · ReliaQuest describes itself as the global leader in AI cybersecurity. Its agentic AI security operations platform, Gray Matter, helps enterprise cybersecurity teams contain threats in minutes and supports trusted enterprise brands worldwide.
Show notes
Waiting to feel confident can keep you from doing the work that actually builds confidence. But what happens when you’ve prepared, put in the reps, and still don’t feel ready?
Drawing on experiences in military teams, professional baseball, and business, this conversation challenges leaders to stop treating confidence as a prerequisite for performance. This isn’t really about looking confident—it’s about developing your capabilities without making every result a verdict on your worth.
In this conversation, you'll hear them discuss how to:
- Build skill confidence through preparation and repeated practice
- Strengthen team confidence by developing and rehearsing together
- Anchor authentic confidence in purpose, not your results
ReliaQuest exists to Make Security Possible, allowing security teams to detect and contain threats within minutes — anytime, anywhere. Our AI powered GreyMatter technology connects with customers’ existing tools and infrastructure to drive greater visibility and automation without the need to centralize data or standardize technology. Built on over a decade of experience, ReliaQuest is the only cybersecurity technology company at scale, at the enterprise, that makes the customer the platform. With over 1,000 customers worldwide and 1,200 teammates across six global operating centers, ReliaQuest delivers security outcomes for the most trusted enterprise brands in the world. Learn more at: https://www.reliaquest.com
Follow "No Show Dogs":
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/noshowdogs
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@NoShowDogs
Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account