The Vergecast
Do we really want Rosie the Robot?
· Summarized
Key takeaways
- Robotics advancements suggest a future where humanoid robots can assist in homes, but whether we actually want them remains uncertain.
- Thread emerged from challenges in the smart home industry to create an interoperable network free from proprietary device requirements.
- Matter aims to standardize smart home integration, improving user experience by encouraging cooperation across major manufacturers.
- Consumer trust and data management are critical concerns; users need to be aware of how their data is being used within the smart home ecosystem.
Summary
The Future of Home Robotics
Colin Angle, co-founder and former CEO of iRobot, discusses the potential for a humanoid robot akin to Rosie the Robot that could manage household tasks. While advances in robotics and AI suggest that such a robot is technically feasible, Angle argues the real question is whether people actually want a humanoid helper. He emphasizes the importance of user trust and acceptance in adopting home robotics, explaining that past experiences with robotic devices show people are often cautious about trusting technology with mundane tasks.
The History and Development of Smart Home Protocols
Grant Erickson, a former engineer at Apple and Nest, shares insights into the development of Thread, the smart home protocol that became instrumental for Matter, the smart home standard. He describes how Thread was created to enable seamless communication between smart devices without the need for proprietary hubs. The discussion highlights the challenges faced during the development of smart home technology and the importance of industry collaboration in overcoming fragmented ecosystems.
The Matter Standard and Thread's Role
The conversation shifts focus to Matter, an interoperability standard designed to make smart home devices work together regardless of the platform. Ericson explains how Matter incorporates both Wi-Fi and Thread, allowing manufacturers to build products that can be used across different ecosystems. He lends insight into the challenges faced by manufacturers in adopting Thread and the importance of infrastructure in ensuring the success of Matter in consumer homes.
Data Management and Consumer Concerns
The episode ends with a discussion about consumer data management and privacy concerns related to Matter and Thread. The Vergecast hotline question raises the issue of data sharing with manufacturers when using Matter-compatible devices. Erickson clarifies that while Matter does promote local operation, manufacturers can still collect data through their individual apps if they design their products that way. This segment emphasizes the balance between local privacy and cloud-based services.
Sponsors
- ServiceNow · Support comes from ServiceNow. We're for people doing the fulfilling work they actually want to do. So that's why this ad was written and read by a real person, and not AI. You know what people don't want to do? Boring busy work. Now with AI agents built into the service now platform, you can automate millions of repetitive tasks in every corner of your business, IT, HR, and more, so your people can focus on the work that they want to do. That's putting AI agents to work for people. That's your turn. Visit servicenow.com.
- Robinhood · Support for this show comes from Robinhood. Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform? With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs. Trade all in one place. Get started now on Robinhood. Trading crypto involves significant risk.
- Shopify · Support for this show comes from Shopify. Starting a business is exciting, but once the excitement wears off, you might realize it also means juggling a thousand tiny tasks. Shopify gets that. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world.
- Kantar · Support for this show comes from Kantar. These days, media channels are overflowing with content and grabbing your audience's attention is harder than ever. If you want your campaign to stand out, you need insights that help you make a lasting impression.
- Solutions with Henry Blodgett · How do we AI-proof our jobs? How do we fix the deficit? How do we get our political system working again? I'm Henry Blodgett and I'm launching a new podcast called Solutions, where every week, I'll talk to an innovative, enterprising expert to cut through the doom and focus on how to build a better world.
Show notes
This week on The Vergecast, the co-founder and former CEO of iRobot, Colin Angle, joins The Verge’s smart home reviewer, Jennifer Pattison Tuohy, to discuss what the ideal home robot is. Are we close to creating a Rosie the Robot — an all-in-one humanoid robot that can take care of our homes, or should we take an entirely different approach to home robotics? They dive into the advances in technology powering this shift and ponder what purpose robotics in the home should really serve.
Then, Jen takes a journey back into smart home history to help us understand its future. Grant Erickson, Principal of Nuovations, a former Apple, Nest, and Google engineer who was part of the team that developed Thread, joins the show.
He shares the story of how and why, back in 2011, the Nest team, led by Tony Faddell and Matt Rogers, decided to create a smart home protocol. It involves a thermostat, fragmented ecosystems, and one of the best smart home products ever made.
They discuss how Thread became the foundation of the Matter smart home standard — an unprecedented industry collaboration with a herculean task — to make the smart home simpler.
To close out the show, Grant sticks around to help answer a Vergecast hotline question (call 866-VERGE11 or email vergecast@theverge.com) about how Matter manages your data.
Further reading:
Maybe I don’t want a Rosey the Robot after all
Amazon left Roomba with a huge mess to clean up
Figure will start ‘alpha testing’ its humanoid robot in the home in 2025
Amazon Astro review: too much Alexa, not enough arms
Samsung is finally releasing Ballie
This Pixar-style dancing lamp hints at Apple’s future home robot
iRobot’s founder is working on a new kind of home robot
iRobot OS is the newest ‘brain’ for your Roomba
Amazon bought iRobot to see inside your home
I tested a robot vacuum with an arm, and my dog may never forgive me
Inside the Nest: iPod creator Tony Fadell wants to reinvent the thermostat
Nest CEO Tony Fadell on Google acquisition
Fire drill: Can Tony Fadell and Nest build a better smoke detector?
How big companies kill ideas — and how to fight back, with Tony Fadell
Situation: there are too many competing smart home standards
Matter’s plan to save the smart home
Nest’s home security system costs $499 and comes with magnetic door sensors
Google says Matter is still set to fix the biggest smart home frustrations
Thread is Matter’s secret sauce for a better smart home
Nanoleaf launches a smart switch after eight years of trying
Thread count: Ikea is stitching together a smarter home
Why Thread is Matter’s biggest problem right now
The four changes in Thread 1.4 that could fix the protocol
It could be 2026 before all your Thread border routers work together
Matter will be better in 2025 — say the people who make it
The Nest Learning Thermostat gets its biggest upgrade in over a decade
killedbygoogle.com
Google’s ADT partnership finally has a new home security product to show for it
Google discontinues Nest Protect smoke alarm and Nest x Yale door lock
Google discontinues its Google Nest Secure alarm system
Appliance makers are teaming up to reduce your electricity usage — and save you cash
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account