The Case for Belief with Ross Douthat

Key takeaways

Curiosity about spirituality is on the rise in a secular age, prompting people to re-examine the relevance of religion in their lives.
Douthat's personal journey illustrates the complexities of faith and the potential for intellectual engagement with religious belief.
The current cultural narrative has shifted, disillusioning many with secular optimism and creating space for a renewed interest in traditional faith.
Modern individuals must navigate the plethora of religious choices available, which can complicate the pursuit of authentic spiritual paths.
Belief is portrayed as an innate human impulse, suggesting that faith can coexist with rational thought and can be meaningful in the quest for understanding.

Summary

Religious Interest in Modernity

The episode opens with a discussion about New York Times columnist Ross Douthat and the cultural resurgence of religious interest in a hyper-secularized world. Douthat argues that modernity has created a longing for spirituality that was previously dismissed as anti-intellectual, suggesting that this renewed curiosity in belief warrants reflection. He emphasizes that the teachings of Jesus should not require the suspension of rational thought, thus making faith accessible to an educated audience.

Douthat's Personal Journey

Douthat shares his personal religious journey, beginning with his upbringing in a mildly religious household, followed by an exploration of charismatic Christianity, and ultimately his conversion to Roman Catholicism. His experiences illustrate a shift from a diverse religious background to finding comfort in the intellectual tradition of Catholicism, which he views as a nuanced path amidst the dynamic landscape of American Christianity.

Cultural Context and Belief

The conversation examines the current socio-political landscape, addressing how events over the past decade, particularly the rise of populism and the discontent with liberal narratives, have prompted a reevaluation of faith and belief systems. Douthat asserts that people are now seeking alternative spiritual frameworks beyond organized religion, hinting at a broader cultural dissatisfaction and the search for meaning in an increasingly complex world.

Challenges of Modern Faith

Douthat identifies several obstacles to belief in today's culture, including a sense of cynicism towards traditional institutions and the paradox of choice that modern individuals face with countless religious options available. He emphasizes the necessity of genuine exploration of faith and the importance of wrestling with the divine, despite the risks involved in such a vulnerability.

The Human Impulse Towards Belief

Toward the end, the discussion shifts towards a broader understanding of belief as a natural human inclination. Douthat argues for the rationality of religious perspectives and calls for a reexamination of the relationship between faith, reason, and communal practice, emphasizing the uniqueness of each individual's path to understanding spirituality.

Show notes

The Bulletin welcomes Ross Douthat for a conversation with Mike Cosper about what makes religion worth pursuing in a hypersecularized world.
Find us on Youtube.
What makes religion worth pursuing in a hypersecularized world? New York Times columnist Ross Douthat explores this question in his forthcoming book Believe: Why Everyone Should Be Religious. Today, Mike Cosper sits down with Douthat for a conversation about the elemental human impulse toward belief and why, especially in this modern age, it’s worth pausing to consider it.

GO DEEPER WITH THE BULLETIN:

We want to hear your COVID-19 reflection. Send a written response or voice memo here.

Grab some Bulletin merch!

Find us on YouTube.

Rate and review the show in your podcast app of choice.

ABOUT THE GUEST:
Ross Douthat has been a New York Times opinion columnist since April 2009. Previously, he was a senior editor at The Atlantic. He is the author of the forthcoming Believe: Why Everyone Should Be Religious. He is the film critic for National Review.

ABOUT THE BULLETIN:
The Bulletin is a weekly (and sometimes more!) current events show from Christianity Today hosted and moderated by Clarissa Moll, with senior commentary from Russell Moore (Christianity Today’s editor in chief) and Mike Cosper (director, CT Media). Each week, the show explores current events and breaking news and shares a Christian perspective on issues that are shaping our world. We also offer special one-on-one conversations with writers, artists, and thought leaders whose impact on the world brings important significance to a Christian worldview, like Bono, Sharon McMahon, Harrison Scott Key, Frank Bruni, and more.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices