DOGE Was Doomed From The Start. Author Michael Lewis Explains Why
· Summarized
Key takeaways
- DOGE had enough authority and young technical talent to improve government, but Lewis says contempt, bad faith, unrealistic budget math, and refusal to work with Congress made failure inevitable.
- Lewis argues that essential government expertise often resides in obscure civil servants such as IRS privacy officers and NIST scientists, whose work protects tax collection, public safety, measurement standards, and wildfire preparedness.
- Lewis says federal reform is necessary, but reductions should be planned with knowledgeable employees and lawmakers rather than imposed by people who first destroy institutions and ask questions later.
- Lewis urges citizens to challenge politicians who make vague claims about waste, fraud, and abuse, asking them to identify specific government problems and name public servants whose work they understand and respect.
Summary
Michael Lewis’s new audiobook rights and the appeal of revisiting old books
Before the formal interview, Michael Lewis discusses having completed roughly 40–50 book tours across hardcover, paperback, European, Japanese, movie, and anniversary releases. He says audio rights to his older books are now returning to him and are worth far more than they were when the books were first published because smartphones and driving have expanded audiobook demand. Revisiting the books has also surprised him: rereading Liar’s Poker led him to revise it, and he found that the updated version speaks directly to today’s AI bubble. It will be released in April with an accompanying podcast.
DOGE could have worked if it had approached government with curiosity
Asked whether Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency could have succeeded, Lewis says yes: DOGE had enormous power and could have been useful if it had treated civil servants as neither idiots nor crooks, learned what needed fixing, and improved government technology. He highlights the age gap in federal IT, estimating that about 60% of government information-technology employees are over 50 and only about 8% are 30 or younger. Musk’s status gave DOGE unusual latitude, but Lewis says Musk’s stated goals were mathematically and practically impossible: cutting $2 trillion while excluding military spending, entitlements, and interest payments, which comprise most of the budget, and refusing to work with Congress.
Lewis framed Blockers around civil servants rather than Musk
Lewis says Blockers is fundamentally about the Trump administration’s broader seizure of power, not simply DOGE’s rise and failure. He describes a two-million-person civilian workforce that formally serves the Constitution and the law, while the administration sought to turn it into a personal instrument of whoever occupies the presidency. DOGE was the opening assault, but Lewis wanted to show how changing incentives affected the people performing government’s less visible functions, including public safety, long-term scientific investment, and data collection. He therefore centered individual employees whose work and expertise were being pushed out of the new environment.
The IRS privacy officer who refused to hand over undocumented workers’ tax data
Lewis identifies Kathleen Walters, the IRS’s chief privacy officer, as his example of an unglamorous but essential public servant. Her job was to prevent politicians or presidents from weaponizing sensitive tax information; employees who improperly inspect returns can be fired and potentially imprisoned. Soon after the inauguration, Walters was asked to provide seven million tax returns filed by undocumented workers using ITINs rather than Social Security numbers. Those records included recent addresses, and ICE wanted them to locate people. Walters lost her job after refusing, although the data was ultimately handed over. Lewis says the episode threatens trust in tax collection.
NIST’s hidden role in standards, fire safety, and wildfire research
Lewis says the government is poor at explaining agencies such as NIST because civil servants cannot advertise themselves and public attention often brings congressional blame. He describes NIST’s origins around 1902, when the country lacked consistent definitions for feet, pounds, minutes, and gallons; the agency’s standards now help regulate everything from gas pumps to measurements. He then tells the story of Alex Maranguitis, the NIST fire scientist who reconstructed the World Trade Center collapse and spent two decades studying wildland-urban-interface fires. Lewis says Maranguitis’s research explains how fences, houses, and communities burn, yet the administration has made his work harder.
Lewis’s advice for reform, his changed views, and Blockers’ possible film adaptation
If Musk had asked for advice, Lewis would have introduced him to Maranguitis, OMB official Tim Curry, who understood the civil service’s problems, and Congressman Jamie Raskin, who could help turn reforms into law. Lewis agrees that the national debt—up $3.5 trillion under Trump—requires action involving entitlements and the military, but says workforce reductions should be designed with people who understand each institution. Research made him think less of Musk, more warmly of IRS employees, and more critically of Congress. His takeaway is that citizens should demand specific knowledge from candidates, including three government employees they admire. He puts a film adaptation of Blockers at roughly 50–50.
Sponsors
- LinkedIn Ads · LinkedIn Ads says it generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. New advertisers can spend $250 on their first campaign and receive a $250 credit; terms and conditions apply.
- Runway · Runway Ads creates creative variants for existing ads, publishes approved versions to Meta, TikTok, and Google, and reports which versions perform best. Its creative suite can generate and edit video, images, and audio. Sign up free and receive 25% off paid plans with code MORNINGBREW.
- Ultra Pouches · Ultra Pouches are plant-powered pouches containing clinically proven nootropics and adaptogens, with no caffeine, nicotine, or crash. New customers receive 15% off with code MBD.
- Global X Artificial Intelligence and Technology ETF (AIQ) · AIQ offers exposure to the AI ecosystem, including software platforms, semiconductor designers, and cloud infrastructure providers. It tracks the INDXX Artificial Intelligence in Big Data Index.
- Waterboy · Waterboy sells daily hydration, weekend recovery, and workout hydration formulas. The hosts recommended stocking up for the holidays and said it would be available on Amazon or Shopify for 20% off starting November 18.
Show notes
#974: Author Michael Lewis returns to talk about his latest book, “Blockers: Rebels in the Deep State,” which offers an inside look at the early days of Elon Musk’s DOGE. Lewis shares stories about several dedicated public workers who tried to maintain nonpartisan government operations while their agencies were being gutted.
You can purchase Blockers here: https://www.blockers.fm
Subscribe to Morning Brew Daily for more of the news you need to start your day. Share the show with a friend, and leave us a review on your favorite podcast app.
Tickets to our Holiday Spectacular are available NOW! https://www.morningbrew.com/events/mbd-holiday-spectacular-2026
Get $10 off with code: MBDPRESALE
Sign up for free at Runway.com/morningbrew and get 25% off with code morningbrew
Subscribe to Morning Brew’s free daily newsletter for news, games recommendations and more: https://morningbrewdaily.com/subscribe_mbd
Listen to Morning Brew Daily Here: https://www.swap.fm/l/mbd-note
Watch Morning Brew Daily Here: https://www.youtube.com/@MorningBrewDailyShow
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account