Q&A - Am I Toxic For Caring? - Short #216 · HVAC School - For Techs, By Techs summary

Key takeaways

It's important to maintain professional pride but also practice personal humility. Focus on the quality of your work without judging others harshly.
Constructive feedback is more effective when rooted in objective assessments rather than personal judgments of co-workers.
Recognize that everyone has different backgrounds, working styles, and definitions of quality, and strive to respect those differences.
Navigating professional relationships requires understanding and managing one's emotions, particularly in response to perceived lower standards by others.
Focusing on personal performance while allowing for the diversity of work approaches can foster a more harmonious workplace.

Summary

Introduction and Listener Question

Brian starts the episode by introducing a listener named Stan, who asks for advice on maintaining a professional relationship with co-workers displaying lower work quality standards. Brian highlights the importance of professional integrity and the challenges of working beside individuals whose standards differ.

Professional Pride vs. Personal Judgment

Brian discusses the need to differentiate between professional pride and personal pride, stating that while it's critical to take pride in one's work, one must maintain humility about personal standards. He encourages listeners to assess the quality of work objectively, resisting the urge to judge co-workers personally based on differing work approaches.

Navigating Professional Relationships

The podcast emphasizes the importance of effective communication when addressing the quality of a colleague's work. Brian urges listeners to offer constructive feedback while recognizing individual differences. He speaks about how contextual factors influence perception and discusses the balance between caring about quality and allowing personal preference in work approaches.

The Complexity of 'Toxicity' in Professional Settings

The term 'toxic' is explored in depth. Brian critically examines the idea of labeling behavior as toxic, advocating for understanding and control over how we express frustration and care. He emphasizes managing one's reactions and suggests that care for work can coexist with personal differences and disagreements in the workplace.

Final Thoughts and Wrap-up

In conclusion, Brian urges technicians to focus on personal excellence without comparing their standards to others. He encourages listeners to channel frustrations into constructive actions and highlights the significance of embracing one's values without denigrating others. The discussion wraps up with a reminder that the quality of work and caring attitudes are vital to the trades.

Show notes

Bryan answers a listener-submitted question: "Am I toxic for caring?" He gives advice on how to maintain professional relationships while still maintaining very high standards of quality for your own work.

Having high standards is great, but it can be frustrating when you perceive coworkers as having lower standards than you. A poor-quality end product is fairly objective, but other ways of judging coworkers' standards are a lot more subjective and may vary by culture, and we end up judging the person rather than the work. While we should care about the objective outcomes of a job, we want to challenge ourselves when we start comparing others' work to our own unfavorably.

Judging others' work isn't inherently bad or "toxic," but it has to be controlled and done in service of something greater. When we confront others or judge their work, we need to make sure it comes from a place of professional pride (rather than personal pride) and personal humility.

As tradespeople, we don't always do the best work, either. In some mission-critical applications, we need to rely on workarounds to get a quick outcome. In those situations, it's a lot more important to be honest about what we're doing and the value we promise. When we find opportunities for our colleagues to do things better, we can offer advice in service of the job and allow the other person to take it or leave it; we don't get to decide that for others. We also have to acknowledge that people have different natural inclinations, and we'd be wise to respect those differences.

Have a question that you want us to answer on the podcast? Submit your questions at https://www.speakpipe.com/hvacschool.

Purchase your tickets or learn more about the 6th Annual HVACR Training Symposium at https://hvacrschool.com/symposium.

Subscribe to our podcast on your iPhone or Android.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel.

Check out our handy calculators here or on the HVAC School Mobile App for Apple and Android.

Q&A - Am I Toxic For Caring? - Short #216