Pumping vs. Compression - Short #218 · HVAC School - For Techs, By Techs summary

Key takeaways

Pumping is related to liquids, while compressing refers to gases, with crucial implications for HVAC technicians.
Circulator pumps in hydronic systems create minor pressure differentials compared to compressors.
Positive displacement systems force a fixed volume of fluid through the system, while dynamic systems vary based on conditions.

Summary

Understanding Pumping vs. Compression

In this section, Bryan delves into the fundamentals of pumping and compressing fluids. Pumping typically involves liquid, which is dense and more or less incompressible, while compressing refers to vapor, which can be squeezed into a smaller space. Bryan also discusses how misunderstanding these concepts can lead to confusion for technicians, particularly when liquid enters the compression chamber of a compressor, potentially causing damage. Engineers must recognize the differences when dealing with liquids versus gases to prevent mishandling equipment.

Mechanisms of Movement: Circulator Pumps and Compressors

Bryan uses a Ferris wheel analogy to explain how circulator pumps work in hydronic systems, emphasizing that the pressure differential across a pump is minimal compared to that of a compressor. He outlines a positive displacement mechanism, where a fixed amount of fluid is trapped and forced through, contrasting it with pneumatic systems that deal with gases and have varying pressures due to their compressible nature.

The Role of Positive Displacement vs. Dynamic Systems

Moving forward, Bryan explains the distinction between positive displacement systems, such as compressors and circulator pumps, and dynamic systems like condensing fan motors. While positive displacement systems maintain a constant volume flow (albeit variable mass flow) due to changing densities, dynamic systems depend on velocity and can vary flow rates based on resistance, showcasing fundamental differences in how HVAC systems operate and manage different fluid states.

Show notes

In this short episode, Bryan clears up the confusion behind pumping vs. compression.

Pumping is usually associated with liquid. Liquid, like vapor, is a fluid, but it's a lot denser and is essentially incompressible because the molecules are close together. Liquid volume varies based on temperature and density, but we can't squish the molecules together. That's why compressors with very little axial and radial compliance fail when flooded; they can't compress the liquid. A circulator pump in a hydronic system is an example of a pump that pushes liquid along, but the pressure difference across the pump is minimal compared to that of a compressor; the same is true of liquid vs. vapor CO2.

However, vapor molecules are far apart and can be squished together to take up a smaller volume. That's why vapor can go through compressors, which take a fluid of one volume and apply pressure to shrink it to a smaller volume, raising the temperature in the process. Pneumatics, as opposed to hydraulics, utilize compression to move vapor around in a circuit. Recovery machines need to be able to compress vapor refrigerant and pump liquid into the recovery tank.

Compressors and pumps can either be positive displacement or non-positive displacement systems. A positive displacement system creates a trap and forces a fixed amount of fluid through a system, like a scroll compressor or a circulator pump. Refrigerant volumes may vary because vapor density varies with temperature and pressure (the volume flow is the same, but the mass flow varies). A condensing fan motor, on the other hand, is dynamic and varies the volume of air it moves in response to pressure, as the mechanism relies on velocity and kinetic energy to move air.

Have a question that you want us to answer on the podcast? Submit your questions at https://www.speakpipe.com/hvacschool.

Purchase your tickets or learn more about the 6th Annual HVACR Training Symposium at https://hvacrschool.com/symposium.

Subscribe to our podcast on your iPhone or Android.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel.

Check out our handy calculators here or on the HVAC School Mobile App for Apple and Android.

Pumping vs. Compression - Short #218