HVAC School - For Techs, By Techs
The Current War - Tesla, Edison & Westinghouse - Short #266
· Summarized
Key takeaways
- Innovation is a blend of ideas, marketing, timing, and courage, not just technical brilliance.
- Perception and safety concerns can be as influential as actual safety in shaping public opinion and acceptance.
- The Battle of Currents illustrates that technological rivalry can drive progress, with each side pushing the other to innovate.
- Modern technologies like solar and EVs show that the 'war' between different power systems continues, fostering ongoing improvement.
- Understanding the history of electricity helps tradespeople appreciate the labor and struggles behind the systems they service and install.
Summary
Introduction and Podcast Context
The episode begins with a casual introduction from Brian of the HVAC School podcast, emphasizing its brevity and focus on an intriguing historical story— the 'War of the Currents'— involving Tesla, Edison, and Westinghouse. The purpose is to explore the lessons hidden within this historic battle and relate it to modern technological and marketing struggles.
The Historical Battle: Edison, Tesla, and Westinghouse
This section delves into the late 1800s conflict over electricity systems— direct current (DC) versus alternating current (AC). Edison promoted DC and built an empire around it, but DC had significant limitations over distance. Tesla, supported by Westinghouse, developed AC, which could be transmitted over long distances via transformers, leading to the eventual adoption of AC for power grids. Edison's propaganda campaign attempted to discredit AC, associating it with danger through public electrocutions and the electric chair, despite AC's safety and efficiency. The Chicago World's Fair of 1893 marked a turning point, showcasing AC's capabilities.
Modern Implications and Lessons from the War of the Currents
The discussion emphasizes that innovation involves a mixture of ideas, marketing, safety perceptions, and timing. Edison, Tesla, and Westinghouse exemplify how each contributed differently— inventiveness, dreamer qualities, and business acumen. The episode stresses that safety perception often trumps raw data in public opinion, and effective demonstration can make a crucial difference in sales and acceptance. Interestingly, DC has made a comeback in modern times with new technologies such as solar, LED, and long-distance HVDC transmission, illustrating how technological battles are ongoing and cyclical.
Conclusion and Key Takeaways
The episode concludes by highlighting how the rivalry spurred technological progress and that the lessons from this history are relevant today. It encourages tradespeople to appreciate the complex history behind the systems we work with, recognizing that electricity’s history embodies innovation, ego, marketing, and courage. The narrative underscores that the ongoing advancements continually improve our industry, and understanding this past makes us better equipped to handle the systems of today.
Sponsors
- Refrigeration Technologies · Refrigeration Technologies at RefridgeTech.com
- Carrier · Carrier has been a long-term sponsor of the podcast. They've made it possible very early on for us to do what we do and they are the products that we sell day in and day out, everything from single-stage equipment all the way up to the green speed extreme, one of the most efficient products on the market today.
- Copeland and White Rogers Sure Switch · Copeland and the White Rogers Sure Switch, the multi-voltage replacement contactor that works for 24-volt, 120-volt, 208-volt, and 208-volt control applications. It replaces over 100 common contactors, is sealed to keep out insects, debris, and moisture, and lasts about five times longer than typical contactors.
- Santa Fe Dehumidifiers · Santa Fe dehumidifiers and the all-new Ultra V155 whole home dehumidifier, which is 40% smaller than the previous model and features an 8-inch ventilation duct and a powerful fan. It supports up to 3,500 square feet and comes with a six-year warranty, including full replacement and parts.
Show notes
In this short podcast episode, Bryan is back for yet another history lesson. This time, the subject is the current war with Tesla, Edison, and Westinghouse.
The current war was fought in the late 1800s with lightbulbs, electrocutions, and a World's Fair that dazzled the entire world. Edison didn't necessarily invent the lightbulb, but he made it commercially viable by inventing the infrastructure needed to make it work; electricity worked one way and performed well in small cases. However, voltage drop was a problem with direct current (DC) circuits; Edison was okay with decentralized (localized) power generation with centralized control under the Edison Electric Light Company.
Tesla proposed a system using alternating current (AC), which could be sent hundreds of miles with minimal loss thanks to a transformer (which could step down high voltages from the utility source). AC power steps up at the utility and then down at several points between the utility source and the end user. This vision was at odds with Edison's DC system. Tesla, who had worked under Edison, sold his patents to George Westinghouse.
Edison began a propaganda campaign against AC power, emphasizing its dangers. However, Tesla harnessed the powers in his lab to demonstrate its potential; while impressive, it didn't necessarily prove the safety to the public. The Chicago World's Fair was the battleground of the current war: both Edison and Westinghouse submitted bids, and the latter's was half the price. The World's Fair was lit purely by AC power and proved its usefulness to the world (primarily to Westinghouse's financial benefit). DC faded into obscurity as a means of powering cities, and although Edison was a showman and salesman, his invention was upstaged when it mattered most.
However, DC made a comeback over a century later, particularly with the rise of electronics, LED drivers, and solar power. It can now move power over ultra-long distances, too.
Have a question that you want us to answer on the podcast? Submit your questions at https://www.speakpipe.com/hvacschool.
Purchase your tickets or learn more about the 7th Annual HVACR Training Symposium at https://hvacrschool.com/symposium.
Subscribe to our podcast on your iPhone or Android.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel.
Check out our handy calculators here or on the HVAC School Mobile App for Apple and Android.
Follow this show on AudioBrevity and new episodes get summarized for you. Create a free account